Do I really need an " Audio Grade Network Switch "?


I think it's been a quite controversial topic for years, like what's the difference between normal network switch and an audio grade network switch, the price difference is certainly obvious though...
Anyway, I've done some researches, most audio reviewers say that under this " new digital streaming era " that an network switch is a must for an audio system, which is understandable for me, I mean because if I wanna play TIDAL or Qobuz or Spotify, I gotta use network so I can stream these online services, so yeah I get that if the network quality is good enough, it can possibly level up the music performance.

But anyhow, I'm new to this area, so I don't like to spend big bucks on my first purchase hahaha... there's a very wide range of the prices though, the top one is Ansuz Power Switch I think, the inner circuit and design look pretty sharp, and surely over my budget lol

So I'm choosing between Bonn N8 and SW-8, these two both got good reviews, and the prices seem so darn much friendly to me as I'm looking for an entry level switch now, do any of you have any insights to share?
or should I just go for the higher level ones?

Best,

preston8452

So both the Bonn N8 (which I own) and the SW-8 use customized TCXO clocks.  Some report even better results using switches with OCXO clocks, like this one and this one.  

To your question, do you really need to spend the money for an "audio grade" network switch - not in my experience.  Setting aside the technical reasons that the clock in the switch shouldn't make a difference when feeding a competent server, and also setting aside what it really means to have an "audio grade" switch (i.e., better clock, more expensive, what makes it "audio grade"?), I simply have not heard a difference.  I run 45 feet of Ethernet cable from my router to my server.  I have heard no improvement or difference between a bunch of stuff I have tried and compared such as:

  • Ethernet cable vs. fiber optic cable feeding my server
  • Bonn N8 vs. Netgear switch, and 
  • Small boxes by UpTone Audio and W4S vs. nothing

There are things I am curious about trying such as the Intona Isolators, ENO Ethernet filter, and the DJM Electronics GigaFOILv4–INLINE Ethernet filter, but based on my experience I just cannot make myself spend the money when I cannot hear any problems with my current set-up - if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

I'd agree I've heard little difference with devices pre server. Its post server where all the meaningful improvements come from. I'm listening to just installed Sonore opticalrendu (powered by Uptone JS2 LPS), wonderful improvement upon SOTM SMS200. I'm now full optical from first FMC which is direct out from server, to usb out to Dac. Prior had two FMC and ethernet cable to go through. Usb out of any server is highly unlikely to be best streaming solution. Optical post server is optimal setup, absolute isolation between server and dac is a must, dont need all these add on filters with this method.

I haven't tried these products - mostly because the premise of improved "clocking", "timing", and/or "less jitter" improving SQ doesn't seem likely given the error correction in the TCP protocol - as well as where these switches are to be installed (before the streamer/server).

In my experience, "noise" in the digital front end plumbing can have downstream effects on SQ, and I have had good results using products that aim to deal with that:  linear power supplies, Gigafoil, ENO ethernet filter.  FWIW, I have what I consider a decent streamer - the DCS Network Bridge.

Looking at a few of the audiophile switches mentioned here, most only market the improved timing, decreased jitter or "data integrity" as the stated benefit.  A few do mention techniques to reduce clock and other "noise", and/or using improved external power supplies to that affect.  I could see these possibly having a benefit.

As with other proposed improvements maybe somewhat to do with your self-confidence. Do you trust your own ears or others ears?

Hi preston8452,  Clearly some people say it won't make a difference, and others say they have tried one and it does.  Very few say they have tried one and it did not make a difference.  But maybe it didn't in their system. Certainly peoples systems and hearing will affect their opinion as well.  I have nice stuff, including nice streamer / DAC, good cables and I am ecstatic with the sound.  I added an EtherREGEN, and to my ears it was a nice improvement.  I then added the Bonn 8 Silent Angel network switch, replacing a Netgear switch, because as you stated, the price was appealing and I wanted to try one.  To my ears, the Bonn 8 improved things again.  Not as much as the EtherRGEN, but I feel it added and was worth it.

I recommend you try one!  Ken