Digital vs analog or both. I have both and appreciate the qualities of each. The convenience of digital is certainly a big plus. However, each media is at the mercy of the quality of the recording. Both have excellent and lousy results.
Analog (vinyl) requires serious commitment. Equipment, media, setup, etc .And, factors such as record cleaning and storage. If you don't already have a large collection of your favorite music then acquiring some of them may be expensive.
Whatever fits your preference is right for you. Just from my own experience....the same recordings of the best quality.....the vinyl will win out every time.