Late to the party, but if you decide to still look for an integrated I would also recommend giving Luxman a try. Either the L-590AXII if you prefer a Class A amp (30 watts 8 ohms, and doubles to 4 and again to 2 ohms, though that's a conservative rating) or the L-509x for class A/B (120 Watts 8 ohms, 220 4 ohms). In addition to tone controls that can be bypassed, Luxman has a very good internal MM/MC phono stage if you need that. I auditioned both before deciding to spend more on the new D'Agostino Progression Integrated, but found both very musical. Also for your situation, MusicDirect sells both of them with a generous return policy so that you can try them in your home without much risk (though be forewarned that they require quite a bit of break-in).
MusicDirect, of course, has other integrated amps (and separates) that you could also try. Crutchfield is another possible source with a generous return policy, though their offerings are more limited.
MusicDirect, of course, has other integrated amps (and separates) that you could also try. Crutchfield is another possible source with a generous return policy, though their offerings are more limited.