What is their impedance curve. If it is highish and stable 40 watts should give you sufficient volume. If they bounce down to 3 Ohms and lower you have cause for concern.
14 responses Add your response
I have no personal experience with the Hansen Prince speaker but reading the specs 87dB and 6ohm nominal seems like borderline case with the Shindo. I pulled up the Stereophile review and in John Atkinson's measurements section, he measured the Prince's sensitivity at 85dB a little lower than Hansen's stated rating of 87dB, however, importantly the speaker does not got below 8ohms between 10-200Hz in the bass region so it will not present a difficult load in the bass region. It does dip below 4ohms in the mid-treble region and up (from about 2.5KHz and up)never going below 3 ohms it looks like. This suggests that with a tube amp, the high frequencies will be a bit of a tougher load on a partnering tube amp and may be somewhat attenuated. Here is the relevant section from John Atkinson's measurement section:
"My estimate of the Prince's voltage sensitivity on its tweeter axis was a little lower than specified, at 85dB(B)/2.83V/m. This speaker will definitely benefit from being driven by a powerful amplifier, particularly as its impedance (fig.1) drops below 4 ohms in the mid-treble and above. The impedance rises with decreasing frequency below 1kHz, which means that tube amplifiers, with their relatively high source impedance, will sound heavier in the bass than solid-state amplifiers with the Hansen. But as the Prince V2's impedance at lower frequencies doesn't drop below 8 ohms, this speaker should work well with tube amps."
Here is the impedance and phase angle graph across the frequency spectrum: http://www.stereophile.com/images/archivesart/408Hanfig1.jpg
My suggestion, take your Shindo Sinhonia amp with you to the local dealer who carries the Prince speakers (if you have someone locally) and try them out. You may get a sonic signature that you like but purely from the impedance graph it sounds like you may have attenuated high frequencies/treble and heightened bass response with tube amps, which may add up to a warmer than tonally neutral presentation.
As for the sensitivity (85dB-87dB vs. your 40wpc amp), if you are in an average-sized room and don't listen at crazy SPLs, you should be able to drive them adequately. But again, if you listen to a lot of rock and like to listen at concert levels than you are likely going to run out of steam with this pairing. Again, take your amps to a dealer and try them out. That will be the best way of determining their compatibility.
Hope this helps.
Many thanks, Cmalak, for that very detailed and helpful answer. It is certainly make me think again about these speakers. The local dealer only has the Knight for auditioning, and this is similarly rated but I dont know whether the impedance differs. But from what youre saying, impedance is the critical factor.
My listening preferences are jazz, and classical and room size is 13 X 20, and I dont listen at high levels, so I dont think that is an issue.
My current speakers are the Ascendo MS, (rated @91db). These are normally used with ss or amps like the CAT so lots of power. Having said that, the Sinhonias are coping with them, but at their limit. It seems from what youve said, by moving to the Hansens I might be going from the frying pan into the fire!! So I guess I should be looking at alternative speakers to the Princes.
Thanks also to Charles1dad.
Kegonsan...generally with mid-power tube amps like your Shindos, you want speakers that are fairly sensitive (90dB+) but more importantly speakers that do not present the partnering tube amp with a difficult load. Look for speakers that are nominally rated as an 8ohm impedance speaker with no dips below 6 ohms. Also the flatter the impedance curve the better as tube amps generally do not like big shifts in impedance across the frequency spectrum. Some speaker brands to think about - DeVore Fidelity, Coincident Technology, Audio Note, Audio Kinesis, and Merlin (plus many others but these come to mind).
Personally, I would seek out the Devore Silverback Reference speakers and audition them with your amp. I think you will like this combo very much. I admit I have not heard speakers from the other lines so I cannot comment on their sound other than to say they are typically tube-friendly and on paper should mate well with your amps.
Boy, Cmalak is on a roll with great suggestions(I own Coincident speakers they`re superb) that`s a very good list of tube friendly speakers. I`d also add Horning and Tonian Lab as potentially exceptional mates with the Shindo amps. I think all the above would match much better than the Hanson speakers i.e. much easier and relaxed load.
It happens to know very well the Hansen Prince V2 since I own them and the Knight as well.
I suggest that you test the Shindos in your dealer's Knights.
Knights are more demanding than Prince V2.
I've heard Princes with Viva Solista mk2 with 24 single-ended watts and the match was fantastic, but needed a bit more power for loud passages in orchestras.
Anyway try with the Knights and if you like it I reassure you that with Princes it will be easier.
I have Emperor in my room 10.5 x 17ft, I thought is going to overload but at moderate level of Aesthetix calypso at 46 setting was beautiful, calypso calibrated at 0db. Using krell FPB600, Aesthetix io sgn. Mk2 with 1PS. VPI classic TT/dyna XX2mk2. Loading at 2.15gm and 1k ohms.
Hansen is a beautiful speakers, I just got it yesterday ,