Artists of the Decade


Looking back ten years, this decade has produced some of the coolest music. Here are my "hits" and "misses":

Hits:

Bruce Springsteen, Bob Dylan and U2 did not rest on their laurels, stayed productive in the studio, toured endlessly with real fire, and ended the decade on top of their game.
Not a bad album in the bunch. Not bad for a bunch of geezers whose collective musical experience rests at 130 years.

The Animal Collective, Arcade Fire, Fleet Foxes, Grizzly Bear and a dozen other young bands went their own way and proved that indie music, produced on small labels, is the sound for today. Quirky yes; boring no. Made me forget the 1960s,1970s,1980s, 1990s, and actually live in the moment.

Radiohead put a bullet in the heads of every major music label by offering their music up at any price. They could get away with this because of the brilliance of the music. Name a better band that so effortlessly put out work as diverse as Kid A and In Rainbows. The new Beatles? You bet.

Hats off to Timbaland and Kanye West for taking Hip Hop to new places. Hard not to admire the ear candy that diverse artists like Missy Elliott routinely served up. And to M.I.A., who made it global, without borders, mixing in sounds at will like a chef adds spices.

And kudos to Apple, whose creative energy designed a device called the iPod and software called iTunes that brought convenience and portability to hundreds of millions of end consumers.

Misses:

Watching talented individuals like Ryan Adams and Elliot Smith self destruct.

Having America buy into the herd mentality of American Idol.

The vinyl revolution. Way too much hype for a medium that failed three decades ago. 2 million units actually shipped; yet thousands of Audiogon posts waxing estatic. Nobody actually talks about the dead wax they own and the wide range of quality problems. I pity the suckers who bought into the 180 versus 200 gram hype.
bongofury
"I like degenerate stuff! BUT IT HAS TO BE GOOD. "

Good is in the eye (or ear) of the beholder. The only objective measure is record sales. If a lot of people buy it, there is probably something good about it I have found.

"Those 'performers' don't reject melody, they are incapable of it. "

What % of rap is this true about compared to other forms of pop music I wonder?

"Let's see one of them try a Motown style vocal harmony."

That's old hat. Others have been there and done that. These guys/girls do something different for a different target audience.
'Good' is based on opinion, but to a point there is a greater cultural standard. Who determines that? Not the consumer, IMO. Thus:

"The only objective measure is record sales"

I am surprised Mapman, I usually end up agreeing with you. I think you might have your scenario reversed. Popularity with the masses seems to generally mean profound mediocrity, with certain rare exceptions. Doesn't the lowest common denominator usually win out in popular circles? Is this even in dispute anymore?

My comments about rap have nothing to do with either morality or a past vs present argument. I am just sick of that monotonous beat with an ignoran perspective on life droning on top of it. It seems unimaginative in the extreme.
"'Good' is based on opinion, but to a point there is a greater cultural standard."

One would hope so.

I'm just saying that high record sales is an objective indicator that a lot of people like something. High international record sales is an indicator that different cultures in different countries like something.

When a lot of people like something, there is usually something good about it, like talent, sex appeal or a catchy tune, to account for that. Of course some good marketing doesn't hurt either. But marketing alone cannot sustain an act with no talent, at least not for long, IMHO.

That doesn't mean that everything good is popular . There are many great recordings with poor sales, but at that point it is more of a subjective thing that cannot be measured.

I suppose things that remain somewhat popular over extended periods of time (after the marketing and hype is gone) and are not forgotten can be deemed objectively good due to longetivity, which is the ultimate measure.

BAch, Beethoven, and other classical composers are good examples. OTher more modern artists, like Ellington, Armstrong, Elvis, the Beatles and others that are no longer around but still have a following are other likely candidates (though The BEatles admittedly still have a substantial marketing machine in play).

In the end though, the only goodness that matters to each of us in the eye of the beholder/listener, I suppose.
>>"The only objective measure is record sales"<<

Really?

Boyz 2 Men
N'Synch
Madonna
Sheryl Crow
Michael Bolton
Kenny G
Britney Spears
Jonas Brothers
Hannah Montana
Nickelback
Any rap "artist" (performer is a better word; artist connotes some semblance of talent)

Wanna rethink that statement?
Here's my list of non-electronic albums for me for the decade. I didn't let any one artist have more than one entry.

1-The Decemberists-Picaresque
2-Built To Spill-Ancient Melodies Of The Future
3-Phosphorescent-Aw Come Aw Wry
4-Rilo Kiley-The Execution Of All Things
5-M. Ward-Post-War
6-The Arcade Fire-Funeral
7-Panda Bear-Person Pitch
8-Cat Power-You Are Free
9-Neko Case-Blacklisted
10-The Avalanches-Since I Left You
11-Bon Iver-For Emma, Forever Ago
12-Iron & Wine-Our Endless Numbered Days
13-Japancakes-The Sleepy Strange
14-Thao With The Get Down Stay Down-We Brave Bee Stings And All
15-Sleater-Kinney-All Hands On The Bad One
16-J Dilla-Donuts
17-Sufjan Stevens-Illinois
18-Band Of Horses-Everything All The Time
19-Yeah Yeah Yeahs-Fever To Tell
20-Stars Of The Lid-And Their Refinement Of The Decline
21-Santogold-Santogold
22-The Microphones-The Glow Pt. 2
23-Ry Cooder & Manuel Galban-Mambo Sinuendo
24-The Flaming Lips-Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots Pt. 1
25-Blonde Redhead-23
26-Tord Gustavsen Trio-Being There
27-Steven Wilson-Insurgentes
28-Bill Frisell-Good Dog, Happy Man
29-Fleet Foxes-Fleet Foxes
30-My Morning Jacket-Z
31-Steve Tibbetts-A Man About A Horse
32-Bohren & Der Club Of Gore-Dolores
33-The White Stripes-White Blood Cells
34-The Beatles-Love
35-Sunn O)))-Black One
36-The New Pornographers-Electric Version
37-A.C. Newman-Get Guilty
38-Wilco-Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
39-Portishead-Third
40-Rainer Maria-A Better Version Of Me
41-Black Mountain-In The Future
42-The Gutter Twins-Saturnalia
43-Brian Wilson-Smile
44-Jesse Sykes & The Sweet Hereafter-Like, Love, Lust & The Open Halls Of The Soul
45-The Black Keys-Chulahoma
46-Pelican-What We All Come To Need
47-Hope Sandoval & The Warm Inventions-Bavarian Fruit Bread
48-Earth-Hex: Or Printing In The Infernal Method
49-Mogwai-Happy Songs For Happy People
50-Nik Bartsch's Ronin-Holon