2. analog
  3. 1123286793

Turntables New vs Used

Thought I would post this as possible food for thought. Have been in this hobby since 1957 and have owned a great many tables both new and used. My first audiophile table was a Dual 1019 and it has evolved from there.

I deal a lot in turntables both new and used, sort of a hobby business. With that in mind in recent years there has been several new tables to hit the market such as those from Music Hall,Project, and so on. Not all but most of the tables in the sub $1,000.00 range are just horrid to say the least. For what one pays in this category,one can find true stellar turntables in the used market.

Used tables from Sota,VPI and Rega will clearly outperform anything from Music Hall, Project and others.

This is not meant to disparage Music Hall or Project or others of the same category. But when one truly looks into what is available in the used market,it becomes readily apparent that the higher end used tables will sonically be superior to the new offerings.

I know for the last few months have had several of the Music Hall and Project tables as well as others come and go through the door.

To be candid there is no black art or voodoo science in turntable design. Physics and Geometry are basic law and are absolute with debate not being possible.

But many of these new tables have seem to have forgotton these basic laws and some of the new tables are pure dreck and I am being kind there.

Turntables from VPI,Sota,Rega,Nottingham,Bluenote,Clearaudio,JA Michell,and Simon Yorke offer tables that firmly place them among the best in the world,with sound engineering principles.

Plus the upgrade path is clearly there for future sonic improvements as materials and science come about.

In addition the price one will pay for one of the used tables make these some of the best bargains for today and tomorrow. However with all things used do make sure of whom you get it from and that you are getting what you pay for.

Don't overlook many of the excellent direct drive used tables from Denon,Kenwood,Yamaha,Technics and others. But do concentrate on thier upper end models forgoing the lower model line up.

All in all the current used market represents far greater value than most of the mass produced new tables.

For instance a Rega P3 is in my opinion is vastly superior to a Music Hall MMF 7 and at less cost, new price to new price. I know I have had both here in recent months. Used the Rega P 3 is a hands down winner in this category.

Both VPI and Sota are easily accessed via phone or e Mail and are most helpful in their product line.

The choice is yours and it is your money.
ferrari
ferrari OP
617 posts
 
Ah yes, I am indeed in the presence of great minds. I am most humbled to be insuch esteem company. It is very refreshing to finally find out that 47 years in this hobby is now meaningless and without merit. One has no idea of what a true blessing that is after all this time. Now I can go on with my life and get degrees in something other than applied sciences. After all basic scientific law no longer applies. Perhaps someone on Audiogon can reinvent the wheel? Then reinvent the vinyl disc to go with that wheel.

Perhaps a degree in World Economics. After all the price of eggs in china are at all time high, and may truly not be worth the wear and tear on the hens ass. Yes I can see it now, a possible new quest.

I must forward all of these posts to M.I.T immediatley as applied science as we now know it, has no value. What a genuine break through this is and from the honored and esteemed Audiogon community. Perhaps someone in this post will receive a grant to further the applied sciences, to a newer and elevated level, no one thought possible. A mighty ambition indeed.

But my most heartfelt thanks to the respondents of this post and the Audiogon membership, to have a burden such as this lifted from my now very tired shoulders, is something I could not envision, yes there is a GOD!!

At 62 I will endeavour to get a degree in something else. After all I made a ton of money with the other, just hated to waste those 47 years though. But maybe by 82 I will once again become a valued and worthy member of humanity.

So I leave this thread to those gifted minds of the Audiogon community, my hat is off to you and I am forever humbled by presence of the Audiogon Membership.
dan_ed
2,451 posts
 
Now that's the Palm Beach I remember! People don't agree with you so you throw out sarcastic insults and slink away with your nose held high. It has been my experience working with other engineers such as myself that if you want to study a subject to death, go find an M.I.T grad. If you want to get something done, go find an engineer who graduated just about anywhere else. I often wonder if they teach the same physics at M.I.T. as all the other schools.
drumsuck
10 posts
 
Ferrari... dude... this is a discussion forum. You don't get to take offense to somebody disagreeing with you.

Audiophilia like any other hobby is all about opinion and personal choices.

Chill out.
david12
1,454 posts
 
Lets not throw the baby out with the bathwater, Johnanntais makes some telling points. In particular, I agree that budget items are important to draw new enthusiasts into the hobby, whilst we old foggies shuffle off to Gods waiting room. I would'nt agree there are less items available, TT's excepted more new names are coming available, particularly from China. You may have issues in trying to support home industry, but the budget market is expanding with good new products, in ampifiers, CD players, speakers etc. I accept there seem to be no new TT manufacturers, but give the Chinese time. Meanwhile there are reasonable budget decks around. I would still advocate a newcomer to vinyl to go 2nd hand, if only because you reduce loss if you make a mistake and wish to sell quickly.
Moving on to the laws of physics, I am a Doctor not a physicist, but last time I checked the basic laws of physics are immutable, certainly the laws of motion, friction, dynamics etc. I don't think TT designers need to employ String Theory. What you might say is that there are many different ways of applying those laws, high mass/low mass, suspended/rigid etc, but sorry, the laws of physics are pretty much a given.
dan_ed
2,451 posts
 
David12, I think you meant to say "Dammit, Jim! I'm a doctor, not a physicist!"

It is interesting that you mention string theory and at the same time claim the the basic laws of physics are immutable. For it is the string problem that defies explanation using the currently known "laws" of physics. I think it is important to remember that physics is itself an attempt by man to model the universe in mathematical terms. Surely we don't presume to get everything right every time? I say this not in light of the discussion here about TT design, but more due to how often I hear "the laws of physics" tossed out in these forums. As an engineer I use many of these laws everyday but I can easily recognize things around us that are not fully explained, yet.
More to discover