Loading speaker stands with?


Rehashing a common question, with a uncommon choice: I will be getting stand mounted speakers soon for a new listening room in my next house. I have always had floor standing speakers, but this room is small so smaller monitors just make sense. Obviously I will have them on stands. The question is do people load their speaker stands with dry sand or shot (or similar heavy dense materials) to stop resonance or to create weight for stability? I know the answer may be for both, but has anyone tried using foam packing peanuts jammed into the legs of the stand, and what were the results? I would guess it would soften any resonance from the metal legs, without creating a heavy, immovable tsand. Thanks for any feedback.

cooperdude6

@shooter41 Cool. For others without platforms, spikes work as advertised only on a rigid, massive floor (concrete slab) where energy actually drains into an inert sink. On suspended wood floors, spikes couple a speaker to a resonant structure — potentially worse than nothing. Decoupling (compliant isolators) works regardless of floor type, which makes it a more reliable default.

As for filling the stands, it depends on where the isolation is. If the platform is under the stand, fill still matters — it damps column resonances that transmit directly into the cabinet via the top plate. 

@thecarpathian 

My apologies I read your post wrong and thought you were confused about how much a quarter mm is. 

+1 for Sound Anchor. 

Recently set up some Omega speakers on SA stands. I used Stack Audio component idolaters under the stands. Big improvement heard by all 3 of us.

 

Steel shot used for abrasive blasting media uses the SAE J444 grading system where the number in the designation represents the nominal diameter of the shot in ten-thousandths of an inch.  So S-110 represents 0.0110 inches, which is 0.279 mm, or just a bit over a quarter of a mm.

FWIW, Sound Anchors uses sand to partially fill their stands. I have owned a bunch of them and they have always worked great for me.