Break In Question?


I have been under the assumption that in order for a component to break in there must be a signal pass through from one piece of equipment to another. That is, running a Dac/Preamp into an amp, the amp must be turned on for the Dac/Preamp to break in.

But is this really true? Does the amp really need to be turned on?

ozzy

ozzy

xmbw4, it makes a difference psychologically and materially. Break in is used by many dealers as an encouragement to either accept a product which is not impressive in demo and/or to hold a purchased product longer in the hopes that you get used to it and like it. 

In my book The Audiophile Laws I discuss the many issues/problems of break in and how to avoid it all. Giving credence to break in is an impediment to advancing a system. 

If break-in was simply brains adjusting to a changing sonic signature, how could we discern the effect of any change in a system with constancy? In other words, to be able to discern any change in our environment, we must have a reasonable constant–which is our brain. If the brain was adapting to every alteration in the environment, we would lose points of sense reference and end up in an amorphous stew of uncertainty. 

Let's not let this go too far off the rails. Break-in is real, completely repeatable and obvious unless you do not possess good listening skills or a sufficiently resolving system. I have broken in dozens of components, and cables over the last fifty years. 

One of the more interesting experiences was that I was able to break in three Audio Research Reference 160 amps. Each of which I had for over 1,000 hours. To my amazement the sequence was exactly the same on each case. Starting trebly and a bit flat and improving through about 120 hours, then wavering wildly between sounding terrible and great... before resuming a slow improvement through 600 hours. 

A unique characteristic of the Audio Research Reference 5SE after breaking was that after each turn on / starting to play music from cold  there would be a very notable jump in fidelity at about fifteen minutes... but if you turned it on without playing music... you still had to play music through it for fifteen minutes before the improvement occurred. I thought it was interesting. Then I saw someone on a forum bring up the very same characteristic. And another owner jumped in and confirmed. The Audio Research 6 / SE does not do this. It sounds great from startup there is no jump in fidelity... other than a very small one. 

I could relate stories about dozens of components and wires that I have broken in over the years. So, let's not get too carried away that it doesn't exist or it's in your head. I've been comparing notes with people with good listening skills and systems for decades and never met with anyone who could not hear it on most good equipment. The degree and details does vary by component. Many components are run long and hard before sale. But there is still typically a break in period. I just recently received a fully broking in amp that sounded terrible for the first day...then was fine again. 

All my components required a break-in period from my cartridge to my speakers. The duration varied however. My cartridge took 50+ hours. My speakers took 300 hours to get top performance. Cables took on average 100 hours. That is part of the experience.

 

@douglas_schroeder 

Giving credence to break in is an impediment to advancing a system. 

You are asserting that refusing to give credence to what one hears is the key to system advancement?