Should AI generated posts be banned or otherwise regulated?


I just wonder. 

At least, when I start a new thread, I am expecting other people's opinions.  I can get my own AI response so I am not sure why others would repeat what I can do myself. 

If someone were to have access to some better AI than I have access to, I guess that would be useful info I could not otherwise get.  But in general, I wonder why posters think responding with AI content is useful to someone who can get that directly themselves. 

jji666

btw, those two paragraphs are from the report, I forgot to say 'exerpt' and put quote marks, sorry.

@elliottbnewcombjr 

The article you shared was published in May, 2025. Light years in what one proposed last year, fast forward to now. 

The real story, as of the this year, is the pushback on data centers and how it is being recognized for what it is - a movement wholly driven by the monies from the top 7 companies in America that is being financed by Wall Street who sells it to the public while wrangling for local resources that are in short supply. They find the weakest links - typically desperate rural areas with local governments that can be easily manipulated by money - in America. 

"As of early 2026, local, bipartisan activism has successfully blocked or delayed over $64 billion in data center projects". 

What I find daunting is that these companies leading the charge are financing it, not using their own revenue to build, complete, and depreciate. Instead, they are borrowing, build, complete and eventually, abandon. There is literally no way the taxpayer or public is going to win this fight or walk away better than before. 

It will most certainly be a relative topic this November. I don't find too many *except for Devin* who are excited about it.

@devinplombier 

The Solow productivity paradox is the observed contradiction between massive investments in information technology (IT) and sluggish productivity growth, famously summarized by Robert Solow in 1987: "You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics". Despite rapid digital advancements, measured economic output per worker has often failed to accelerate correspondingly, particularly in the 1970s-80s and again in the 2010s.

In the 1960s,, predictions suggested that rapid advancements in computing and automation would power the American economy, with 37 experts advising President Johnson in 1964 that a "Triple Revolution" of technological change would displace workers. However, this led to the 1987 Solow productivity paradox, which observed that computers were visible everywhere except in productivity statistics, as adoption did not initially boost efficiency

The current data that has been observed does not represent an AI curve. So far, AI is doing just what technology has done in the past - fail to deliver.

What your writings conclude is just what we already knew. America cannot build a battery. We suck at it. In fact, we lost. Game over. 

Personally, I would buy a Chinese BYD car tomorrow if one came on the lot. Half the cost of an American EV. 

And there are Chinese cars creeping over the borders in Texas via Mexico as we speak. 

Chinese-made vehicles, banned from direct US sale in 2025 due to national security and data risks, are appearing in Texas border cities like El Paso via a Mexico loophole. Residents are spotting brands such as BYD and Geely, brought over by Mexican residents legally allowed to drive foreign-registered vehicles.

All of that data came from AI. So powerful you can't argue with me!

 

 

 

 

 

@goodlistening64 

I was not arguing the merits (or demerits) of AI. I was pointing out that if broad tech history is any indication, AI's energy footprint will plummet in the future even as its output increases exponentially. 

Whether that's good or bad... is another conversation 😃

America cannot build a battery. We suck at it.

Tesla builds plenty of batteries, as do many others. If you meant to say "America cannot build a battery cheaper than the Chinese", then you are right.

In fact, we lost. Game over.

Yeah? Could be worse. We could be Europe 😂

 

output increases exponentially

Well GDP was +2.0 in first quarter 2026, up from +0.50 from last quarter 2025. Is that the exponential component? 

Tesla builds plenty of batteries, as do many others

China currently maintains a significant lead over the United States in the battery industry, particularly regarding manufacturing capacity and supply chain control. As of 2024, China possesses approximately 85% of the world's global capacity for battery cell manufacturing.

...using your smartphone AI forces against you! The Truth cannot be challenged!