Can you help me decide between these two?


I have asked and all said seek a new turntable. I am using a Technics SL-Q3. I have come to these two choices. Michell Tecnodec or Acoustic Signature Primus. can you provide info as to which? Obviously buying both used. I do have a Benz SL cartridge but that I may or may not use. 

dpm2340

I didn’t bother learning about your existing TT until others here suggested keeping it.

So I had Brave AI gather the basics. 

The Technics SL-Q3 is a fully automatic, quartz-locked direct drive turntable released in 1979-1980 that is widely regarded as a high-quality, durable unit from the height of the "turntable wars." It features a brushless DC motor, a 31.2 cm aluminum die-cast platter, and a static-balanced S-shaped gimbal tonearm with a rotational speed deviation of only ±0.002%

Key specifications and features include:

  • Performance: It achieves a wow and flutter of 0.025% WRMS and a signal-to-noise ratio of 78dB, with speeds reaching constant rotation in just 0.9 seconds

  • Design: The cabinet uses a two-layer TNRC acoustic material for anti-vibration, and it supports auto-start, auto-return, and repeat modes while accommodating 7", 10", and 12" records. 

  • Tonearm: The arm has a 7 mg initial motion sensitivity and uses a quick-change headshell compatible with standard 1/2" cartridges (such as Audio-Technica, Shure, or Ortofon), rather than the P-mount found on cheaper models. 

  • Value: Users frequently describe it as a "poor man’s SL-1200" due to its robust build and accuracy, often finding excellent value in the used market for around $200-$300.

  • //////////////////////////

  • IF it is setup properly, and you can mount/align/calibrate a new cartridge (or have a friend who can) (or live near me 07062), I would certainly buy a spare headshell (with azimuth adjustment) and put it on your existing TT.

  • After that: Any New/Used TT, I would want a Tonearm with removable headshell.

So I can address a few replies: I don't use a turntable much either. But I do want a quality unit worthy of a 1 to 2 grand cartridge. Also, the SL-Q3 is automatic. Thanks for looking up the specs of my turntable. As far as I know I have it set up properly. 1st the overhang is determined by their gauge. Once installed on the turntable you zero out the tonearm to be level. Then adjust the tracking force. Anti skate is dialed  to the tracking force number. That is the directions. Not sure how the results would differ doing it some other way. Another thing with the Technics is the rca plugs and wires are thin, thin, thin. Connectors are cheap. thanks

My suggestion is either, keep the Technics or the Mitchell.

My years in this insanity I have often been caught in this dilemma. 

All specs, price and reviews somewhat equal. Cartridge I have will do well upon both.  At one time, passed "Wife Acceptance Factor".  I found myself going with the "Cool" factor.  Sounds good when playing a record.  Looks good when just sitting there. As it did 97% of the time. Two seconds.  First impression.  Thinking back, I have always been this way.  The first time I saw this new Garrard Zero 100.  That far back.  Oooo.  Bought it.  When I saw the B&O 4002, Oooooo.  Bought it. When I saw an Technics SP-10 with a Dynavector 505? tonearm. OOOOooooo!  Price set in, Ughhh.

However.  On the other hand. 1980's.  There was the Linn LP-12.  Usual turntable but sounded sooo really good!  Never owned one.