Some of this depends on the sonic signature you are looking for as well as the strength of your desire to reduce the number of boxes in your system. Below is a comparison between the MA3i and the Innuos STREAM3 with the internal PhoenixDAC board. Of course, the STREAM3 is also a server and can run Roon core, which eliminates one more box. However, I usually rank sonic preference slightly above convenience, but not always.
Comparison
- If you prioritize a slightly smoother, more organic, "analog-like" flow, the Meitner MA3i is generally considered the stronger contender.
- If you prefer a highly energetic, punchy, and "live-in-room" presentation with superb resolution, the Innuos Stream3/Phoenix DAC is often preferred.
- The MA3i is praised for its "magic" ability to be detailed yet incredibly smooth.
- The Innuos setup (Stream3+Phoenix DAC) is recognized as a formidable one-box (or rather, "one-chassis") solution that rivals much more expensive separate components.
Both devices are premium, but they suit different sonic preferences regarding warmth versus energy.

