This is a great discussion post with lots of good points made. I agree with those who mentioned it will often depend on the speakers. I've had speakers with binding posts that prefer spades, other times they are terrible with spades. Same with bananas where sometimes the binding post angle makes it really impractical to keep a solid banana connection.
All things being equal, I might prefer a spade if I knew I would not be changing anything for the long term. Knowing my style I do like swapping gear often so a well made banana connector works better from that point of view.


