Should Room Acoustics be an Audiogon ‘topic’?
The available topics on Audiogon do not include Room Acoustics. This area is as important as any other, and has a far greater impact on what we hear than amps, preamps, and cables put together, IMO. Does anyone know how to lobby to include it? Do I need to start a petition? ; )
@wyoboy Thank you. Your comments have done an excellent job of framing the issue. Clearly many are conflating room treatments with acoustics in the broader sense that concerns me. The subject of how to deal with our rooms is a subject that is appropriate in this forum and there should be no reason for debate.
|
"Part of my motivation to make this a separate topic is to bring it to the forefront. It has been ignored too long and there are so many sound systems posted on Audiogon with wonderfully sounding and well-curated equipment that languish in a morass of bad reflections. Having room acoustics as a separate topic codifies its place in hi-fi and you ignore it not at your peril, but rather as a waste of money because you are not hearing what you paid for as well as you could." |
Where’s @mahgister ? This is right down his alley. Hope all is well. |
@tcutter No argument here that it's the most important component of your system. But having said that what else do we say? We can all change components based on others' recommendations and discussion but we generally can't change the dimensions of our rooms and probably not the materials that compose it so maybe the topic should just be "Room Treatment" ? @mapman I'm surprised he hasn't chimed in as well but when he does on acoustics it's usually at a doctoral thesis level that most of us don't understand. |
@mapman @wyoboy
"I consider my hobby was once, in the period i learned it about : acoustics and his relation to the three others workings dimensions +Psychoacoustics factors... For most people instead of being the ground of audiophilia it is an optional decorative ceiling... The main business of audio threads is marketing, well inspired or not ...
This will not change... People dont read books and anyway nobody experiment under his wife eyes in a living room ...
I am done with purchasing (except for replacing a broken piece) I learned acoustics. Now my hobby is music and A.I. studies...
«Your wisdom is useless as are those answers for a question never asked»-- Groucho Marx philosopher |
"