Garrard 401 or Thorens 125

What kind of a floor does your sound room have?  If it is spongy at all pick the Thorens.  Otherwise, either one is good.

Something else to think about thanks Bill!

I owned a TD125 for many years.  It was a gorgeous modern looking TT in its day, and I think the looks hold up well.  However, be aware that there were some electronic problems with the drive system.  I think there was an early version of a motor controller built into the plinth that could be uppity. That said, I never had any such problems with mine. The 401 has had more attention in the modern era (i.e., that last 10-15 years) from DIYers and aftermarket plinth makers.  So you might say that the 401 has more upside potential.  I am not aware of any efforts to upgrade the TD125, on the other hand.

If “quiet” is a very high priority, particularly freedom from rumble, the 125 is a better choice.  But, like many idler tables, the 401 sounds punchy and lively.  A local dealer in my area puts that table into many systems north of $100k; the only modern table he sells as high end is an Audio Note table, everything else are reconditioned idler tables.