@squirrely ,
First I got a quintet of Genalex Gold Lion 12AU7 long plates. There was a definite upgrade over JJ, but after a short while, I got a matched quintet of Amperex from '65. Gotta tell you, NOS stuff is becoming more expensive now than just a few years back. But in any case, Genalex is a very solid new production tube.
You can buy just three good tubes and leave the two tone control tubes inside, but I did all five. Now, the phono part uses three of the 12AX7 type. Never replace it with 12AU7. If you're going to use it, you have to get a really strong, quiet trio. Again, Genalex makes solid 12AX7 short plates. For NOS, I hope others will chime in.