I miss scarcity


This is not a complaint. Or, if it is a complaint, it's half-aimed at me. Mostly this is a reflection.

In the old days, I got to know music really well -- in great detail, sonically, musically, reading all the credits, the liner notes, etc. A friend would have an album I didn't, so I'd go to his house to listen. We'd talk about the music. We'd talk about how album sides hung together or didn't. We were thrilled by double albums.

Now, a torrent of information is everywhere. I listen alone, often to a single song, often not listening to anything over and over again.

You will tell me, "That's your choice." I'd half agree. It's like agreeing that "It's my choice not to live off the electrical grid." 

As I read and teach about AI, I am learning that our tools often prioritize speed and information glut. It seems, initially, like a cornucopia but it becomes a wash of "content." I must admit, I'm losing my talent for managing all this content, and I'm losing my love for it. And it's making me into a different person, somewhat, and I am not so sure I want to be that person. End of reflection.

Wizard Conjuring Cosmic Chaos Art Print featuring the drawing Let There be Content by Benjamin Schwartz

hilde45

Wow, what a topic that has led across a number of thoughts.

Regarding the Music experience and scarcity and abundance.

I like Roon for the interface into the music and exploration. It has easy to follow cover art, liner notes, credits, reviews, lyrics all linked so that I find it most like my original exploration into vinyl LPs. I can explore and discuss with friends and chase other versions of the song/composition or individual artists, writers, composers to go deeper into music places I may not have gone to before. I don't need the distributed streaming of Roon (small apartment), and I am not sure It offers the best sound quality, but I like the interface for music exploration and understanding. Apple Music has some of it, but not the same breadth and depth available for exploration. If anyone has recommendations for a similar or better immersive experience, please let me know.

 

Regarding the branching into AI and social dissociation.

I think that the term AI at this point in time is used for a number of computer assisted things that are not all the same, nor even related, so discussion goes all over the place.

There is an AI that has so much computing power that it can work from a fixed set of rules and project results faster than a human and pick the best outcome. Think Big Blue or the GO example. Great accomplishments, but not what I would consider Intelligent. The initial rules are fixed, and the only outcome choices are win or lose (binary). Useful for some cases where the rules are well defined and the outcome is always binary.

There is an AI that just links massive amounts of data by numerous classifications that allows one to gather information about any topic and explore it to any depth desired. It is massive database with link clues. Not really intelligent. Someone had to construct the link clues.

The next level or iteration of that creates a human language interface to those link clues so that a person can ask a question and get a number of responses based on the question. A little bit of intelligence, but it is constrained by social and language norms that are culturally and time dependent, and those depend on a human to construct the context.

Both of these version of AI I find can be useful and help with learning as long as a person remains aware of the variability and bias of the link clues and language constructs.

We are now entering an era where AI is being pushed to where the link clues and language constructs are being abstracted to patterns that expand the possibilities. That allows this computer thing to compose writings, poetry, music and images seemingly Intelligently. I get uncomfortable at this point, because some person created the abstraction of the pattern and language, and that is locked into the social and temporal norms of that particular person at that time. A lot of bias and social hierarchy are a part of that abstraction. Is the result Intelligence? I am not sure, and I do not believe it is really intelligence without the emotional and historical inputs that only a person can provide.

There are those who believe that the next step is when we create something that constructs its own abstract patterns to link things and give them a value weight to make independent decisions. That is truly scary. To me it is not human intelligence, and I do not see a way that it can contain emotional, social, or temporal weight to make any of its decisions human friendly.

To me human intelligence is a merging of sensory and emotional patterns that have social and temporal context that leads to a decision or action that may not be win or lose (binary). This is also where creativity originates in my view.

Sensory patterns are somewhat fixed, but can vary by individual. Emotional patterns I don't think are fixed. They seem to change based on hormones and environment. And social and temporal patterns can have similarities but also seem to be in a state constant change.

I hope we do not drift away from emotional, social and temporal patterns as living beings and never see all things as needing a binary solution.

Enough for now..

I do miss the excitement of finding a hard to find LP ... though it's great that with streaming there are very few hard to find albums...but yes, something has been lost in all this...

budjoe, Good analysis of what AI is (or isn't). 

John Galt would be turning over in his grave if he knew. :-)

@llg98ljk 

More and more album notes and more are included with the music on Quboz. Often the liner notes are a PDF and there may also be a link to the web for the album. Over time, I am sure this will be standard with all albums.