I'm in a similar position, with a McIntosh C2700 preamp, currently using its DA2 DAC but am looking for a more musical/emotionally engaging experience. I borrowed an MSB Discrete DAC from my local dealer for a couple of days and had a rather interesting experience - when I connected the Discrete DAC to balanced inputs on my C2700 I wasn't terribly impressed, feeling that it wasn't notably more enjoyable than the DA2. What got interesting is when I connected the Discrete directly to my power amp. It was a completely different experience and had the sound I was seeking - very open, and completely engaging. One of those experiences where I wanted to keep listening to more and more songs.
The downside is that the Discrete (as well as the Premier above it in the MSB lineup) doesn't have an option for an analog input. I no longer have a turntable but I do have a surround processor (McIntosh MX123) that I feed the front left and right channels to the C2700 in Passthru for watching video. So for me this would mean a completely separate setup and getting a couple other speakers to connect to the home theater setup.

