Many factors are at play...
So much than most people dont realize...
Your point about microphones is really good point...
Why "sound liaison" recording album are so good ?
They used ONE MICROPHONE...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQtwN4zO8is
Interesting stuff! It makes me wonder if the reason that some uncomplicated recordings (I mean a Blumlein pair of microphones, not post-processing or manipulation, like the old Opus 3 recordings) sound so good because there is no opportunity to introduce various tracks that are out of phase?

