Decided to try a SPU cartridge


I’ve been fascinated that the SPU (Stereo Pick-Up) cartridges, which was invented over 60yrs ago in 1958, still has loyal fans today. The SPU is reported to have a big, bold, exuberant and musically exciting character.

While researching, the best SPU cartridge may be the Ortofon SPU Century. I found one new at a greatly discounted price so I took the plunge.

Normally, it’s best to demo before purchasing. But because I’m going for sonic variety rather than improvement, the SPU’s sonic description and market longevity is enough for me to feel confident it’ll be a good experience. Besides, trying to track down a SPU demo in this Covid environment may be a pain.

In addition, I’ll probably purchase a Ortofon SPU Classic GM E MkII to experience the “original” SPU sound. Other SPUs I may try are Ortofon’s SPU Meister Silver GM MkII, SPU Synergy GM, SPU Royal GM MkII, SPU Wood A.

Next I’ll have to get a SPU tonearm. The usual suspects are Thomas Schick, Groovemaster II, and Ikeda. I wonder what’s the best SPU tonearm?

I suspect that tonearm cables upgrades won’t yield enough sonic improvements for SPUs.

kennyc

@dover 

Thanks for the info.  Trying to determine which SUT to purchase - seems like a daunting task that I'll likely try at a later time.  I have been eyeballing a Zesto Audio Andros Allasso SUT on sale now used for $2k.

@alan60 

Wow, thanks.  After very much deliberation, I was targeting a Kuzma 4point as the next tonearm purchase (in addition to a SPU tonearm) and was just debating on which tonearm wire so I reached out to Fremer.  You now report that the ViV is better for the SPU.  I have a Lyra Edna and a Koetsu Redwood Signature Platinum, do you believe that the Viv is superior or just different than the 4point?

 

FYI - it is reported that the Glanz tonearm may be the best for SPUs.  It runs ~$8k

I don't think HTA = zenith.  The term HTA is relatively unfamiliar to me but as defined here it is the same as "Tracking Angle Error", the angle by which the cantilever deviates from tangency to the groove, TAE is the term I usually use.  TAE or HTA is changing as the stylus traces the LP and the tonearm rotates on its bearing.  Zenith is relatively constant, if the reference point is the LP surface.  I It changes as the TAE, if the reference is the orientation of the stylus in the groove, but it is not identical to TAE/HTA.  I am not planting a flag here, but it is a good idea if we all speak the same language.  I certainly can be wrong.

This whole HTA discussion highlights that if you want accurate alignment, you should only buy

- cartridges with conical/spherical tips

or

- cartridges that have a nude mounted square shank diamond and the cantilever has been laser cut.

If you are spending $5-10k on a cartridge, spend another $100 to have it independently inspected by a cartridge retipper. I have seen several $5-10k cartridges with styli mounted askew/cantilevers mounted incorrectly ( rotated ).

I'm planning to have all my cartridges reviewed by WAM Engineering - I'm of the belief that because of cantilever and stylus manufacturing alignment inconsistencies, the best way to align a cartridge is to get the stylus angle correct (vs aligning by cartridge body and/or cantilever).  IIRC. the resulting WAM reports will tell me how much the stylus if off perfect alignment so I can compensate by adjusting the cartridge body.  I'm somewhat concerned that some SPU tonearms may not allow zenith adjustment if needed.

@boothroyd 

The Rigid Floats fly in the face of all known theories of cartridge alignment, if you are using a standard style cartridge like the SPU Royal N the Nelson Hold headshell is a thing of beauty. Remove the headshell and just pop in a full bodied SPU and Bobs your uncle. It is one of the easiest arms to set up, the only slight issue is height adjustment which is easily overcome by using playing cards as shims. 

@kennyc 

The Kuzma 4points are fantastic arms the 9" is a Pitbull terrier of arm, with the 11" and the 14" being more relaxed, for the 11" and particularly the 14" you need to use relatively low compliance normal bodied cartridges and you can only use Nude SPU's. Are the Rigid Floats better? It comes down your own ears.

Strangely whilst mine is a 9" it's positioning is very close to that of a normal 12".

A general tip with Rigid Floats whilst in theory they are free standing they do benefit from being bonded to the armboard/plinth with double sided sticky tape or even better and if you are really brave gluing it with a few dabs of epoxy.