2. misc-audio
  3. 166294-93199

Is it safe to use a higher amperage rating fuse?

Today was my 2nd attempt at trying out Synergistic Research fuses.  About 3 years ago when I had separates, including mono block amps, I bought a set of Blue fuses.  One component had a mfg spec of 250mA and the retailer said go with 315mA.  My two mono block amps each had a 6.3A.  When I installed them one of them blew upon powering up.  The retailer said we should go up to the next rating.  I was a bit frustrated at the experience and didn't feel comfortable putting higher values in my expensive components.  I felt these expensive fuses should be made to tighter tolerances than the cheap BUSS fuses I had been using.  If I remember correctly, that was the actual argument that the dealer told me.  They are mfg to tighter tolerances so a 5A SR fuse was almost dead-on 5A while a cheap fuse may actually be 5.3A or whatever.  This also was a bit confusing at the time so I sent them all back.

Okay...3 years have passed and now I have a single integrated amp which has a 5A fuse.  Much less to invest in the upgrade so I ordered an Orange.  It came in today...installed....pressed power...on and off went the amp.  DAMN!!  I contacted the retailer and SR on the same email.  This was a different dealer from 3 years ago.  The retailer said I should go to the next value up.  I said no and and they are waiting for the tracking info of my return shipment.

I did a quick search of my question before posting and saw a thread about the Red fuses and someone said they had to do the exact same thing.  Is everyone putting higher rated fuses in their gear that is worth thousands of dollars?  Is there no risk in this?  I admit that I don't know what could actually happen from that.  It seems that other things could burn up if a higher amperage fuse is in place.  I am compelled to simply stick to the mfg specs for something that I don't understand because I don't want to create problems just from a simple tweak.

Should I let them ship me a 6.3A or just be done with this?
dhite71
pauly
1,012 posts
 
@grannyring 
Do you have any more detail on the use of breakers? I've never tried them, but on the face of it it does seem like a good idea and I'd like to explore. 

Thanks
arizonabob's avatar
arizonabob
85 posts
 
I'm confused (get it)? What am I missing?
OP stated 250mA fuse (1/4 of 1A)
Suggested a 5A (20 times the mfg suggested current and still blows?)
Did I miss something or is something really wrong here? I'm not an electrician, but I did stay at a Holiday Inn last night.  AB
dhite71 OP
276 posts
 
@arizonabob Maybe you skimmed quickly...you did miss the point.  Read again and see if you have any feedback.  
jetter
2,951 posts
 
Another rather unpleasant thought is that one reason designer fuses blow when they shouldn't is that the makers of such fuses have one goal in mind, to maximize profits.  That would entail buying the cheapest fuses from the cheapest manufactures ($.05 each?), adding their "magic" touches, and then selling them for the most profit possible.  Having to replace a few of the really defective ones, no biggie.

Never underestimate the profit motive.

dhite71 OP
276 posts
 
It seems like a very poor business strategy.  Most, I would say 99.9% of the people would want to replace a fuse in their gear with a matching rating.  This is what any MFG is going to recommend as they should.  

It simply doesn't make sense to me.  I can be very cynical but I don't think the entire industry is a scam where they are simply taking cheap fuses and painting them or whatever.  I believe there is engineering, R&D, etc. involved, but I don't understand why their fuses cannot handle current the way a 'stock' fuse can.  This should be priority #1 in designing a fuse.

I DO NOT believe that all 'stock' fuses have incorrect specs and are allowing different values of current than they are claiming.  I believe the mistake lies with these high end fuses.  So if that is the case, why don't they correct this where people don't have to send back blown fuses and then try plan B with a higher value fuse.  This has left me without confidence in their product.  


More to discover