@optimize I could not have stated it better.
Look. I don't have my shop any more, so I have no skin in this at all, but what I learned, given that I could lock the door and LISTEN to every speaker of any quality on the market at the time for as long as I wanted to, was that Jim Winey had discovered something amazing. No matter WHAT speaker I tried with the best hardware sources--master tapes run down to home r-t-r, Sheffield recordings, even a tape my old band made in the studio, there was NO comparison, period.
OK, I do exaggerate a bit. Robert Fulton had a speaker--I think the Fulton 100--that was AMAZING for a box. Not sure what or how he did it--only met him once at the old CES in the 1970's, but told him that as he was entertaining many other dealers at the time. So yes, there was a good box out there then and I am certain that today, given the hard work many others have done, that there are boxes that are not bad. (I do find it interesting that today's designers seem to like very tall boxes--wonder where they got THAT idea??). BUT, Maggies reveal everything, and as you posted, they are capable of providing "hifi nirvana;" what more can you ask for?
Cheers, and happy music listening!
Look. I don't have my shop any more, so I have no skin in this at all, but what I learned, given that I could lock the door and LISTEN to every speaker of any quality on the market at the time for as long as I wanted to, was that Jim Winey had discovered something amazing. No matter WHAT speaker I tried with the best hardware sources--master tapes run down to home r-t-r, Sheffield recordings, even a tape my old band made in the studio, there was NO comparison, period.
OK, I do exaggerate a bit. Robert Fulton had a speaker--I think the Fulton 100--that was AMAZING for a box. Not sure what or how he did it--only met him once at the old CES in the 1970's, but told him that as he was entertaining many other dealers at the time. So yes, there was a good box out there then and I am certain that today, given the hard work many others have done, that there are boxes that are not bad. (I do find it interesting that today's designers seem to like very tall boxes--wonder where they got THAT idea??). BUT, Maggies reveal everything, and as you posted, they are capable of providing "hifi nirvana;" what more can you ask for?
Cheers, and happy music listening!