You should have just used the same value caps as the originals. Second-guessing the circuit designers is not a good idea!
Do electrolytic caps need burn in?
I tried swapping a pair of amp/preamp line output coupling capacitors (DC blocking). The stock units were run of the mill Panasonic electrolytic. I put in Mundorf Mlytic AG. I know this particular Mundorf (and most large electrolytics) are for power supply use, but the application calls for a large 6800uF so that the system can be used as a small amp or preamp. Since I'm using the unit mostly as a preamp, I guess I could go about 1/10 the size and try to use a film cap.. but anyways, that is besides the point.
The question here is, do electrolytics (specifically this Mundorf) need burn in? I ask because I'm hearing the opposite of what most people hear on caps that are not adequately burned in. The usual complaints with caps without proper burn in are lack of bass, shrill highs, etc. The Mundorfs have increased the bass output and possibly added some texture to the mids (the good), but the highs have disappeared. I'm wondering if the highs will come back over time? I wouldn't say the top is rolled off, but it is just shelved. Any details that are carried in the upper frequencies is obscured and recessed. The life of the sound has been sucked out. Hopefully this doesn't qualify as "audiophile" tuned warm sound.
I have considered putting a small Russian teflon cap in parallel to the Mundorf, but the values I have are too small to probably make a difference (820pF). I also don't think this bypass should be required to get nominal levels of treble in the first place.
I've got about 5hrs on the caps now, and they sound exactly the same as time 0. So are the Mundorf's going to open up the highs with time, or should I just move on to another cap? I will try the bypass before I throw in the towel on the Mundorf. The point of reference is the stock Panasonic caps, which are fairly neutral, with good top end extension and detail.
The question here is, do electrolytics (specifically this Mundorf) need burn in? I ask because I'm hearing the opposite of what most people hear on caps that are not adequately burned in. The usual complaints with caps without proper burn in are lack of bass, shrill highs, etc. The Mundorfs have increased the bass output and possibly added some texture to the mids (the good), but the highs have disappeared. I'm wondering if the highs will come back over time? I wouldn't say the top is rolled off, but it is just shelved. Any details that are carried in the upper frequencies is obscured and recessed. The life of the sound has been sucked out. Hopefully this doesn't qualify as "audiophile" tuned warm sound.
I have considered putting a small Russian teflon cap in parallel to the Mundorf, but the values I have are too small to probably make a difference (820pF). I also don't think this bypass should be required to get nominal levels of treble in the first place.
I've got about 5hrs on the caps now, and they sound exactly the same as time 0. So are the Mundorf's going to open up the highs with time, or should I just move on to another cap? I will try the bypass before I throw in the towel on the Mundorf. The point of reference is the stock Panasonic caps, which are fairly neutral, with good top end extension and detail.
- ...
- 24 posts total
@manthik If the caps needing to form up is what is happening, leaving the caps charged is the best way to do it. Cycling it takes longer- weeks or months instead of days. @jb0194 If new caps in a PSU, will the temporary inefficiency manifest as possibly less responsiveness to peak demands by music at higher listening volumes? In other ways?Yes, and in other ways. We won't even let our stuff out of the shop until it has at least a day on it, because it sounds so 'dead' prior to that. You can measure the form up too- as the caps get more efficient, the voltage on them goes up and they also run at a lower temperature. |
@roberjerman, I am using the stock value. There is nothing to second guess here. It is a simple high pass filter network with a primary function to block DC. The value could be changed according to the implementation, if desired. The designer's intention was for the unit to be used as a preamp and amp. Since I only use it as a preamp, I can adjust the value accordingly. Thanks Atmasphere. I haven't let the unit run in yet, but I'll do that by this weekend and report back. |
- 24 posts total