Good Achtung Baby CD? I got a bad one.


Achtung Baby is probably my favorite US album. When it first came out I had it on cassette tape. Then, years later acquired it via iTunes. Always listened to it on OEM car stereos or low end systems.

Now that I've got my high end system I do not like the SQ of the standard compressed iTunes version. So I did a little research on the dynamic range web site dr. loudness-war and purchased a cheaply priced copy of the Island Records CD (314-510 347-2, cat # D125174) that rated pretty highly on that site in regard to dynamic range anyway.

Well, it does not sound good. Way too bass heavy and bass is a muddy wall of background noise, midrange and vocals seem lost in it all, treble is okay. It seems like the dynamic range is concentrated in the high and low ends. I noticed on the CD that it was "Manufactured for BMG Direct Marketing, Inc." I'm assuming this was a club CD. It was new (old stock). Don't know if that might be part of the problem or not.

I compared it to Tidal's high res version (but just from my laptop to pre-amp via RCA cord, no DAC) and even that sounded better than the CD but still not great in my opinion.

So I'm wondering, who has a CD of this album that they like? I do not have an SACD player or BluRay. Or do all the CD versions sound so-so? That would be surprising for a band like U2 but still possible I guess. Any recommendations much appreciated.

George


n80
A BMG club release will never sound as good as an original issue by the record label.
The DR is damn fine for a CD...
http://dr.loudness-war.info/album/view/48335

Take a look at a look at a 1991 UK or Europe release; CIDU28, 510347-2.
https://www.discogs.com/U2-Achtung-Baby/release/2456311
All versions...
https://www.discogs.com/U2-Achtung-Baby/master/20774

I buy all my Cd’s at Discogs.

Yes, the DR looked good but I guess it is the BMG SQ that is the problem.

Discogs looks to be European (GB) based. Any issues with high shipping costs to U.S.?

Also, I did not explore but Discogs does not seem to have SQ ratings or reviews.

The Steve Hoffman site has been recommended for that sort of thing. I may need to so a search there too.
Right, I use Steve Hoffman for info on SQ. Discogs is best for finding the early CD and LP releases. Amazon vendors have no idea what version of a CD they are selling.

I'm sold on German and Japanese pressings. Also the best for vinyl original releases, IMO.

Shipping from Japan is expensive. Very fair costs from UK and EU.

n80
the CD in your possession is defective in some way. I own hundreds of BMG cds and do not have any degradation in sq.  Good advice as above on imported versions.  Happy Listening!
Don't have a dog in the fight for cds, but I own several lps from record clubs that sound fantastic!