" So its really up to the software to assure accurate rips or not. Not sure how exactly one can achieve that based on drive type alone so I think that is a witch hunt. Better ones will rip faster because they operate faster with fewer errors along the way."
That's one reason why it would rip faster, but if you're comparing full size internal/external optical drives to the small drives like they use in notebooks and usb powered internals, the full size drives work much faster regardless of errors.
Its also worth noting that ripping is hard on the drive, so I wouldn't use anything expensive.
" I’ve seen EAC and it is good as well I believe but some may find it harder or less intuitive to use,"
There's several setup guides available online that walk you through the config process. It only needs to be done 1 time. After that, its just as easy to use as dbPoweramp.
That's one reason why it would rip faster, but if you're comparing full size internal/external optical drives to the small drives like they use in notebooks and usb powered internals, the full size drives work much faster regardless of errors.
Its also worth noting that ripping is hard on the drive, so I wouldn't use anything expensive.
" I’ve seen EAC and it is good as well I believe but some may find it harder or less intuitive to use,"
There's several setup guides available online that walk you through the config process. It only needs to be done 1 time. After that, its just as easy to use as dbPoweramp.