New or Upgrading Pre - Pro

Good question. First out of the gate, the MX136 does not decode the latest high definition surround sound audio formats from Blu-ray such as Dolby True HD and DTS-HD Master Audio. Just so you're aware of that. If that's not a priority, then you're good to go with the McIntosh. But, consider that a brand new surround sound processor in the $2K area (i.e. Rotel) would be an excellent machine for the money. In fact, that's my next upgrade someday when I can swing it.

McIntosh Labs equipment is in another league and is really very high end. Not really apples to apples. Everything about McIntosh is mucho dollars!! My audio store just took on their line and I got the tour of their components and systems recently. All I kept seeing was dollar signs that I know I'd never be able to afford nor would I really want to. I'm very happy with my mid-fi equipment system comprising Rotel, NAD, Marantz and B&W. I think you'd be happy too. What components do you have now in your system? If you buy a processor, you'll need a multi-channel amp to match. Hope this helps guide you. Keep the discussion going.

With a 7.1 analog input and a BluRay player like Oppo BDP-95, you can still enjoy the new Hi-Rez formats, just not decoded in the pre/pro. All you really give up is the room correction, which the Mac doesn't have anyway... The Mac should really be seen as a great preamp that also happen to include processing for HT

If you are planning to use the pre/pro as a multi channel preamp only, rather than getting an older Mcintosh, you are better off scooping up the used Bel Canto MCH pre that is currently listed. What this will not give you is decoding of MCH coming in on your satellite receivers. If this is not a factor to you AND 2 channel analog performance is more important than MCH, the Bel Canto + Oppo is a good option. Keep in mind though that a modern 2K pre/pro has room correction, which may be beneficial for your 2 channel system as well. It will also give you bass management if you have a sub. So you would get an inferior preamp, but with more features. The benefits of room correction, could offset the lower grade preamp. If your soom sucks it probably will. So tough call - many variables.

A variation on Edorr's thoughtful post:

If you are using a (or a pair of) subwoofer(s), this is IMHO a no-brainer: find the best digital bass management/room correction you can afford. If you're not using subwoofer(s), then I'd agree with Edorr - it's a tough call.

Marty