Try it and see.
Yesterday I recieved a new pair of tubes. I put them in and they were not good. Made me appreciate the ones I'm using. Both are 6SN7s from the 1940s but vastly different performance.
You will either hear something like this or your won't.
Many people describe ICs like a wine reviewer writing for Wine Spectator. ...and a hint of manure....often more than a hint. My belief is that passive components can only take away, they don't add. So if both ICs sound a like, neither is removing much of the goodness.
jerry