Please suggest bookshelf with best bass response under $4000 pr.


Lately, I've been craving deeper, tighter bass. I'd like to hear some ideas for replacing my Silverline 17.5 monitors. Is this a stupid question, due to inherent limitations of driver size imposed by typical bookshelf dimensions, or might I actually do better with another speaker? Amplification is Wells Audio 150 watt SS Majestic integrated. Source is aging Jolida JD100 tubed cdp (in new year, I plan to replace this with another SS cdp or a transport/standalone dac combo). Thanks ! 
stuartk

Showing 1 response by jon_5912

Theoretically a smaller driver with greater excursion can go deep but at the expense of sensitivity.  Ports or transmission line can extend frequency response down as well.  There's no substitute for a big driver in a big box, though.  In my experience you can never get the same visceral impact from small speakers, with or without a sub, that you can get from big ones.  If you're determined to try, the best way to go is active.  Active bass is better.  I consider an 8" driver to be the smallest driver that can begin to give a satisfying punch and go deep enough to not sound wimpy or low resolution on music with siginificant bass content.

Is there some reason you absolutely can't have floorstanders?  Small floorstanders with a pair of 7 or 8" woofers will have a far better chance of satisfying you than another bookshelf speaker.  If you've got your SIlverlines on stands the amount of floorspace taken up will be about the same.