Ian Anderson Or Fried?


Looking for some advice on which of these to choose. Has to be one or the other, can't be both as much as I would like that.

Ian Anderson: Started out as a slashing, bluesy rock outfit (I still like Cat’s Squirrel and A New Day Yesterday), evolved into catchy riffers with supposedly socially significant lyrics — always a bad sign — then descended into dubiously progressive English folk music with lyrics like, well, think Lewis Carroll with s*** on his shoe. A flute runs through it. This guy is unpolished but I would say there is a limit to how bad he can be, what with 30% Ks and 53% GBs. Without any growth he figures to be erratic but an asset at the end, and with growth he can easily be a Top 10 SP in 2021. Well-publicized, there is a fair chance that Ian gets the helium.


Max Fried: Legendary Transmission Line Designer. He’s good, with every chance to get better, and he pitches for a very good team. So far, an ideal No. 2 SP. However, his 50 Ks ranked in a three-way tie for 62nd among his peers. Take him as a No. 2 and he pitches 180 innings — that’s granting him something — you get 161 strikeouts from your No. 2 SP. You can do it and win, but you have to be aware of that little hole you have dug. As a No. 3 SP this is less of a concern because now you can afford to roll the dice that Fried’s rate improves. That bet is better because if he doesn’t improve you still get an overall asset.

I like them both but am slightly partial to Fried only because I absolutely love my Roger Sanders Transmission Line Hybrids.
Deadline for my decision is April 1st at 1:05 PM Eastern.

middlemass

Showing 2 responses by tonykay

April 1st, very appropriate (just a little early). Ian Anderson is a rock icon, and deserves better than this.
Like stereo5, I have been a serious Tull fan for decades and have even seen them live (nowhere near 36 times). However, I was unaware of Martin Barre’s interview where he discusses the breakup of Jethro Tull. It was clearly a shock to him, and although I empathize with him, I’m confident that he will be alright with his estimated $50 million net worth. I have an outsized library of Jethro Tull tunes and I’ll continue to enjoy them, but I am disappointed that Ian Anderson may not be the unselfish hero I had envisioned since the 1970’s.