Esoteric DV-50 or Meridian G-08.2 CD Player??


I just sold my krell kav 280 cd player and will be upgrading my digital source. I was originally looking for the esoteric X-03 or X-03SE but these are few and far between, and a bit out of my price range. I do not have any sacd's but have heard that the esoteric DV-50 is a good alternative for a cd player. Should I get the DV-50, or the well acclaimed Meridian G-08.2? I am also considering possibly an accuphase player. My budget is $2500. My system consists of the following:

Amp: Pass Labs X-250.5
Power Conditioner - BPT 2.5 Ultra Signature
Preamp- Krell Kav280P
Speakers- Totem Forest
Cables- Audiopath Custom Eight wire Silver (by Tom Hills at Hudson Audio)
CD Player - see thread... looking to upgrade esoteric, meridian or accuphase.

Any thoughts or recommendations is appreciated. Thanks.
roor

Showing 1 response by kennyt

I can help a little, maybe!

I have lived with the DV-50s since new (I actually paid to upgrade it to 's' status which was wasted money now but that's another story) and for a long time ran it and a G98DH through a Meridian 861v4, in this setup the G98/861 would be a bit better than just the G08, but this is what I found for differences.

They were both very good players, the Esoteric is a bit more accurate and precise while the Meridian combo was slightly more musical. That said the attack was better from the Esoteric while soundstage was larger with the G98/861, who also had slightly more air and separation.

I often found myself using the G98/861 for CD's more but when I wanted to spin all kinds of discs, I used the Esoteric mainly as the G98 didn't do SACD (and now the new G96 doesn't do DVD-A anymore)

So both are excellent choices depending on what you want, for me, it depended on what I was listening to and my mood, somedays I chose one, some days the other, hopefully I have given you some idea why I did this, but honestly on some days it there wasn't a reason, I just chose one over the other!