2. digital
  3. 128120-10135

Comparing these CD players with my gear...

Hi folks, 

I'm always messing around with CD players. A longtime audio friend of mine says I have a CD fetish... well, he's probably right. In a medium that is slowly dying, I'm still spinning discs more than ever. I stream too, but there still something awesome about taking a CD or LP and placing it in/onto a machine to play the sweet music we all love. 

Anyway, in my latest jaunt for something new, I've put together my latest list of players that have caught my eye for one reason of another. My gear consists of a Creek 4330SE integrated amp and Vandersteen 2C speakers. Cables are DH Labs Q-10's and Air Matrix interconnects. 

So what are your thoughts/impressions/comments on the synergies of the following CD players and how they would sound with my gear. I'm most curious about the Naim, Cambridge Audio and Myryad. 

Naim CD3.5
Cambridge Audio 840c
Myryad MCD600
Cal Audio Labs Icon mkII Power Boss
Marantz CD6006 (or CD6005)
Rotel RCD-1072




jsbach1685
georgehifi's avatar
georgehifi
10,312 posts
 

NAIM AUDIO CD3.5  = TDA1305  CDM12.5 / VAM1205


CAMBRIDGE AUDIO azur840c  =   AD1955A  Sanyo SF-P101N


MYRYAD MCD600 = CS4396-KS  KSS-213C


California Audio Labs Icon mk II HDCD = 2 x PCM1702 – PMD100

Panasonic RAE0113Z



MARANTZ CD6005 = CS4398  Sanyo SF-P101N



ROTEL RCD-1072 = PCM1732  KSS-213C / KSS-213CL


Looking at the dac converter chips, and transports/lasers, for Redbook cd replay.

 I'd go for the CAL Icon, it's got a very good Burr Brown PCM1702 Multibit chip, and the HDCD PMD100 filter chip.


Cheers George  


mgreen27
147 posts
 

"Looking at the dac converter chips, and transports/lasers, for Redbook cd replay.

 I'd go for the CAL Icon, it's got a very good Burr Brown PCM1702 Multibit chip, and the HDCD PMD100 filter chip."

Why not look at the analog section of the dac as well? It accounts for half of the component and has just as big of an effect on SQ as the digital half. Also, listing individual parts like the dac chip and filter shouldn't be relied on too heavily. The overall design is far more important. There's plenty of CD players that share the same parts, but sound completely different. 

mtbrider
150 posts
 
+1 on the Marantz SA8005.
itzhak1969
515 posts
 
The Cambridge Audio Azur 851C is superior CDP with DAC and pre amplifer capabilities, Really great contender to your list.

http://www.theabsolutesound.com/articles/cambridge-audio-azur-851c-cd-playerdac/
charles1dad's avatar
charles1dad
10,233 posts
 
Hi Mgreen27,
Your comments/observations are true. Placing emphasis on the particular digital chip is short sighted. 10 CD players or DACs could use identical chip sets and sound completely different from each other . I’d pay more attention to the "quality" of the analog output stage and the power supply. These 2 factors in my experience are more influential and impactful in the overall sound quality.
Charles
More to discover