Listening and evaluating equipment and systems.


I have found that listening to music is far more complex than simply hearing sound. A quick audition can reveal whether a system is bright, dull, thin, congested, or initially impressive. It tells us much less about whether it allows us to live with music… to relax into a performance, follow its structure, and keep discovering something in familiar recordings.

Critical listening can be useful, but it can also mislead. When we focus the mind’s ear on one sound… a drum strike, cymbal, vocal phrase, or bass note… much of the rest of the music recedes from awareness. If that sound is intermittent, we are only sampling brief fragments while other instruments are entering, fading, sustaining, and interacting. A speaker is never reproducing one isolated sound. Everything happening at once affects the whole presentation.

Music is a gestalt… rhythm, tone, dynamics, timing, space, harmony, and emotional intent occurring together. A system may impress by spotlighting details, yet prove less convincing over hours or days of actual listening. Another may seem less spectacular at first, but preserve the natural flow and wholeness of a performance more successfully.

The better test is to stop moving attention from one audiophile cue to another. Play complete albums over days or weeks and let the music direct your attention. A few minutes of analysis may identify a trait. Extended, undirected listening will tell you whether the system is truly right.

ghdprentice

@stuartk 

Know the field... know the house sound of the major brands, and components,  how they interact with each other,  and have deeply immersed in live acoustic music to know what I wanted. Definitely not engineering grasp of circuits, different capacitor’s sound...etc.

 

If I was designing components... then would have taken that approach. I think you would have to be able to take an audio component and swap five different capacitors in a particular circuit and listen, then do it with resistors... then change design with the same components, etc. So, I think that would be the arena where that would be possible and useful. 

I always listen critically.  The sonic detail only enhances the music and I am always listening for new things that I may have missed in the past.

I built my speakers specifically to bring out detail and this makes things sound live, as if they were there in the room.

No, you probably wouldn’t hear this level of detail 10 rows back in a live concert, but when was the last time you hosted a live concert in your listening room, with no extraneous noise, to listen for it?

https://youtu.be/HXfZSbnD4pM

@ghdprentice 

 Hence took me a long time to realize I had to sit back and not listen so hard.

 

I'm going to try this...

 

 

Think back on my systems. I realize they often lend themselves of a way of listening. I used to have a system I called my "reference system", because it was so good at highlighting the venue and nuances of the mastering. Ambience would hit you in the face and each instrument was isolated and analytically and somewhat sterilely presented for examination. I would get bored listening to it after one album, and I would go do something else. 

This just wasn’t obvious to me until I upgraded my headphone system to the wonderful Woo 300B headphone amp with Takatsuki 300B tubes. This system became so musically powerful and natural sounding, it quickly inspired me to turn on my main system to continue listening. I literally had the blood drain out of my face and upper body as I was confronted with a dry cardboard like sound, filled with sterile sounds striped of warmth and natural sound. I remember the disappointment I experienced from this amazing $70K collection of electronics (worth far more than both my cars at the time). I had spent decades putting it together. 

I am condensing a few different epiphanies into one to make my point. 

That was the turning point. Over the next 15 years I completely turned around my main system to where it is today. I really have a difficult time listening to my system for more than a few seconds... the music draws me over and I forget about listening to the system. 

So, thinking about it... your system also pushes you to naturally listen in a certain way.