dman, let's get back to some basic issues. You said you changed VTA from 1.0 to 0.5, and that helped with brightness. What does that mean exactly? VTA is not measured in numerical units, normally. Before that you did not seem to realize that your Luxman 595 is what is called a full function preamplifier, meaning that it has both a linestage and phono section built onto one chassis. You were complaining it was too loud. Once you learned that it has an attenuator (volume control), did you then cure the loudness problem by using the attenuator? Or have you been reporting since then about using your other preamplifier? If you had a dealer set up your vinyl system, it seems they ought to be holding your hand a little bit to get the bugs ironed out. By all means, you should be using your 595 which is way superior to the other preamp/phono you mention. (Forgot the brand name and model.)
So, first explain what you did with VTA. Then I urge you to reinstall the Luxman and use its controls to get the sound pressure level you want. THEN let us know if you are at least happier.

