- Honorable Mention: Jones & Cerreta
This room generated masterful hype with the large posters in prominent places in the 2nd floor common areas of the hotel as well as by gating entry.
Indeed, this dual-concentric field-coil driver has that field-coil magic, and the room was superb overall.
Transients (guitar, when I noted this) have ESL-like purity and speed. The speakers are perfectly-balanced, very dynamic when required, and have no bad habits at all.
However, decay and nuance were not reference-class.
Of course, that could have been due to anything. I neglected to take note of the vinyl front-end, but, as with the push-pull Lab12 amplifier, this was clearly not a spare-no-expense exercise - perhaps more of a "see what our speakers can do with everyday electronics" thing.
However, IMO, it was not SOTA sound in most respects. I think my ear just prefers a wideband driver outside of the bass range, and push-pull tube amps are never my cup of tea. The long decays and very natural treble I hear with SE amps were not present.
- Honorable Mention: Popori (Now Prodigio) WR2/Atma-Sphere
This, like last year, was one of those rooms with jaw-dropping potential.
As with the Martin Logans, that electrostatic purity *probably* cannot be obtained in any other way (jury is still out for me regarding wideband field-coils).
The AtmaSphere electronics are first-rate - and you'd never know those switching amplifiers are just that - and they use a crosstalk-canceling DSP solution as well.
A few lines from my raw notes:
-- After Songer Field Coils: Excellent, but no better in purity or speed AFAICT, and maybe a bit too sterile
-- Treble purity is first-rate
-- Bass Dynamics (Nardis): Volume was too low (ran out of gain?), but deep bass not really there, and bass dynamics soft
The DSP rep contrasted the speakers 8 Khz crossover (to a small (ribbon?) tweeter) specifically as superior to the Martin Logan solution of a crossover on the bottom. However, one of the ramifications of this choice is a low peak SPL limit - 105 dB as spec'd. For me, that is a deal-killer.
- Honorable Mention: High Water Sound
Jeff Catalano has been absolutely masterful at both system-building and setting up show rooms for longer than I can remember. His room - always vinyl-only, always tubes, always some kind of horns - never disappoints (his excellent and electic musical tastes being part of that equation).
As always, the sound was simply divine.
And an uncanny quality is how greatly similar the sound is even when he changes almost all the gear.
If one wished to find nits, the bass was a bit diffuse, and lacked extension - but for the types of music these systems are designed for, this is not really an issue.
- Honorable Mention: Rethm Maarga
I owned Jacob George's first model of Rethms (ironically, the "Second Rethm") as well as at least one pair of his subsequent, powered-bass speakers.
I don't think that cabinet design is the best way to get great sound out of a widebander, but the Maarga here sounded very good, with single-driver speed and coherence, and no glaring bad habits.
- Honorable Mention: Lu Kang Audio/TIEN Audio
This room was running simple two-way monitors & vinyl and had really, really great sound. As I told them, I’d take that system over some of the $500K rooms.
The horn tone sounds like 300Bs but these were small Class A/B SS amps.
- Honorable Mention: Bruno Audio
Two-way hi-efficiency, 12” woofer, horn-loaded tweeter, both Neo magnets, with 300B amp. Virtually reference-class sonics here - perhaps very, very slight, occasional horn coloration.
Great tone, dynamics, detail, but did notice some bass smearing - not as bad as most boxes.
- Honorable Mention: PAP/LAiV
Last year, this was one of the top three rooms at the show IMO, and the gear and the sound were the same this year. Great balance, tone, dynamics. Pink Martini sounded about as good as I’ve heard it. Horn tone about as good as it gets. Transient speed and coherence from the excellent Voxativ driver.
Brief comments on selected other rooms:
- Pure Audio Project/Pass
Unlike the PAP/LAiV room, this one sounded - mediocre. I was not at all impressed by the Beyma coax driver.
- Wilson/REL/D’Agostino
I spent very little time these days in the "Large Box Speakers With Expensive SS Electronics" rooms, but, in prior shows, I have been pretty impressed by the Wilson/D’Agostino sound.
It was as expected this year. The room was actually run by REL, demoing their subs used as line arrays.
[Fun Fact: I once owned a Basis Ovation turntable owned previously by D’Agostino. I purchased it from "The Audio Pimp" in NY, who informed me of the previous owner, and I confirmed that with Dan in person at a show later.
Last I'd heard, The Audio Pimp was in prison.]
- Quad (2912X)
The Quad room was running the larger model (2912X), with Quad electronics too.
Having owned the 2905 (the previous version of the same speaker) and numerous 63/988/2805s, I know the sound well, and here it was: Superb clarify, instant transients, but that very slight glassy sheen and odd bass resonance.
The horn tone was to die for. As it should be with any electrostatic.
- Audio Note
I was really looking forward to the Audio Note room this year because they were to be running the field-coil AN/E.
I have previously owned a full Audio Note Kits system, which I built - phono stage, preamp, DAC, amps, speakers.
I grew past that sound, but Audio Note always does a great job of making music at shows.
Also, last year, Peter Q. himself was running the room. Back in the day, I corresponded a great deal with Peter about why he settled on that old Snell design for his speakers, the benefits of TX-coupling, and other things. He was the head of one of the most respected hi-fi companies in the world and I was just some guy, yet he clearly spent hours on those emails.
Alas, both times I visited the room, he was engaged in conversation, so I didn't really get to chat him up.
And this year, unfortunately, Peter was not present, and, in addition, IMO the sound was simply - off. In particular, I heard some splashy treble that sounded like vinyl tracking distortion.
- Fern & Roby
I'd wanted to hear these widebander monitors. Vinyl. Only Ok. A bit bright, muddy. Not impressed.
- PAP/Consonance
Last year, the Consonance room was a real gem - they were getting absolutely fantastic sound from their own shoebox monitors and a parallel 300B integrated SET.
This year, a push-pull amp was in the mix, with other speakers, which I failed to note. It was still good sound, but nothing out of the ordinary.
- GIP
This firm makes Western Electric theater speaker replicas. They were running them here - field-coil woofer, of course - with a small horn tweeter, and alternative to the large segmented WE-style treble horns. Power was a small Leben integrated.
The sound was superb, but, yes, there are colorations - this type of thing is, I believe, chasing a particular sonic signature.
- Rockport/Axiss
IMO one of the major high-end box speakers that gets closest to ESL-style transients, along with YG, is Rockport. And the sound here was indeed very good (and should be for the price).
- AvanteGarde Trios with AirTight ATM-3211 (Push-Pull 211s)
As I previous Trio owner, I am familiar with the sound - fast but always large and rather "vague." The speakers *can* be time-aligned, but, that's going to work only in a single plane, and the lack of coherence of this paradigm is a killer issue for me.
(I concluded, after several front-horn systems, that that topology is not a win for any sort of real-world home environment. The narrow bandwidth of such horns necessitates many (at least three, as in this case) drivers with, obviously, a passive crossover as well. Though the directivity is a nice effect, unless you want to play at 120 dB - and you shouldn't - this isn't the path to nirvana for any genre of music.)