Well ..This Is Interesting...What Do You Think.?? Food For Thought..Or BS?


Ran across this on Youtube. Bob Carver Takes on Conrad Johnson & Stereo Review

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsAFLhcfHXM

 

mrkrichman

Its a pity that Bob Carver had his name associated with the Crimson 275 tube amp, a poor design with grossly fraudulent specs [...]. Completely at odds with his prior work.

Yes, the Crimson episode was a disgrace, though Bob comported himself quite graciously throughout the whole thing (to add insult to injury, the Crimson also suffered from unsafe grounding).

However, overinflated specs, hype, vaporware, value-driven manufacturing and dodgy safety have always been hallmarks of Carver gear since the Phase Linear days. But so have innovation, talent and (when planets aligned) engineering brilliance.

I’ve restored several Carver pieces. I have an early TX-11 tuner that looks like a scary, factory-bodged mess inside, but it sounds great and it outperforms tuners that were far more expensive back in the day. As always, it’s complicated. 

 

Can we get a SS amp to sound like an Audio Note Ongaku, Berning, or top AR amps?

I question the inference that comparing the vintage Yamaha to a current model represents ALL of high end SS.  

If you are old enough, this info was splashed all over the place back in the day, and the "Challenge"

Gotta love Bob Carver.  This is a great hobby.  Looking at, reading about and dreaming about top end equipment I will never be able to afford and wouldn’t buy even if I could is part of the fun.  Don’t get me started on cables that cost more than my car.  Most people spend to their budget whatever floats their boat be it stereo equipment, cars, boats etc.  My main stereo is much more expensive and definitely sounds better than my first one I put together when I was a kid.  I trust my ears and suggest others do the same.  I have chosen equipment that I auditioned that cost less than other equipment because it sounded better in my system, in my room listening to the music I love with my old guy ears.  It’s okay to dream even if it’s just a dream. 

It's extremely interesting, but like pretty much every aspect of audio ignores the fact that absolutely none of the equipment we enjoy listening music and speech through makes any sound at all. Just as everything is invisible in the dark... suck the air out of a room and you'll hear nothing. All any of this equipment does is generate vibrations in the air that surrounds us. It's our brains that construct the music etc. It's all neurological. A person can be hypnotised to think they hear a trumpet whenever they see a kazoo played.  It's only the fact that we all share an evolved 'neurotypical' perception that we can agree on anything.  I've worked in environments where literally nobody else can hear the whining of the photocopier in standby mode. It drove me insane... needless to say I am probably not neurotypical, but I can enjoy more from music than your average Joe.