I hope this turns out well for you. My one and only experience with their products was not good. I bought a used ECI 5 MKII integrated amplifier from The music Room. Right after it arrived, it had a problem. I returned it to TMR and they "fixed" it. A few months later an intermittent crackling noise developed in one channel. I took it to a local repair shop and they said they were told by another tech familiar with the brand not to touch it with a ten foot pole because of soldering issues. I then shipped it to an authorized repair center. They "fixed" it, and when I received it back, it still had the problem. Long story short, it is poorly made gear and if / when it develops a problem, good luck. I ended up selling it for parts. If it's not too late, run, don't walk.
WAITING FOR THE LATEST PURCHASE TO ARRIVE- ELECTROCOMPANIET EMP-1/S SACD-CD PLAYER
As some of you may know, I purchased a used Marantz SA 1 SACD player for a low price not too long ago. I knew it needed work; the display was black, and the player wasn't reading discs correctly. I repaired it, then chose to refurbish it a bit with new audio caps and new power supply caps. It really is a fantastic-sounding player. Despite its age (20 - 25 years old), it will outperform much newer SACD players costing $2000 - $4000, but the SA 1 was, after all, $7500 new, but again, long ago!
I just did something, and I hope that I didn't make a mistake. If I did, it could easily be fixed. I bought a 10-year-old Electrocompaniet ECP-1/S SACD-CD Player. It includes the factory remote, it's in very nice condition, guaranteed to be fully-functional, and it was very highly praised by TONEAUDIO magazine.
HOW IT HAPPENED: While the SA 1 is working fine now, and I did find 2 brand new lasers for it, I am concerned due to the age of the unit and the fact that, Marantz does not have a single part available for this player. I realize it's a disc player, but it was $7500. One would think that they'd keep a few key parts around for such a premium product. The Marantz Parts Policy, as I was told, when the model has been out of production for 10 years, they dispose of the parts. I asked him to verify "dispose". He made it clear that it means "throwing the parts away". Just between you, me, and the fencepost, I think that's nuts. It is, however, a phenomenal-sounding player in its current refurbished status, seriously threatening the analog dominance currently present (which totals $18K). That is really saying something!
The Electrocompaniet player (moving forward, the ECP-1S) was offered in both stereo and surround versions. The surround version was over $9000 new, and the stereo version was over $8000 new. It was said by Jeff Dorgay of TONEAUDIO magazine that unless you had a truly extraordinary analog system, this player will do fine. He also did comparisons against a $15K Wadia 781SE and the SimAudio Moon 750 at around $13K through his reference system, and said between the three, it was a matter of taste, with the ECP-1 offering a more "analog" kind of sound.
Another reviewer for TONEAUDIO stated that the ECP-1 exceeded his reference player, an Ayre 5xemP, for ease of the sound, grainlessness, dynamics, bass slam, and low-level detail retrieval.
I cannot ignore this. So, the player I bought was a killer deal. We'll see how it sounds. I know that if nothing else, WORST case, I can get my money back out of it. It does offer balanced outputs (which is great). It doesn't weigh anywhere near what the Marantz does, but the Marantz SA-1's weight is largely due to overbuilding of the chassis. If it were put in a normal chassis, I wouldn't be surprised if the weight dropped by 50%.
This was a chance to get into something newer for a very reasonable price that may just sound superior. THAT is what I'll be finding out. I will, for the sake of a good time, keep updating this post as things go along.
JUST A NOTE: Before purchasing, I did check on parts availability. They have parts!! Laser assemblies, transports, and entire replacement boards. If I keep this player, just to be safe, I will be purchasing a couple of spare lasers.
- ...
- 8 posts total
| Post removed |
Unfortunately, that is the case with too much gear now. As the industry is moving (and in many cases, has moved) away from through-hole devices in favor of surface mount devices, and away from hand soldering in favor of oven/hot air/flash soldering, if a particular component has a problem related to a board, its very likely that product will continue to be a problem until that board is change out with one that was (hopefully) soldered correctly. This kind of thing can be an absolute nightmare. I don't discuss it much, but I had a Marantz SA-11S2 that had this problem on the main board that contained the power supply, analog circuitry, and digital/analog conversion circuitry. It was a constant battle. Other people I knew with them were not having the problems I was, but I got a board that was soldered too cool, and who knows how many boards went through there before the problem was discovered! Hopefully, that is not the case here, but if it is, I'll simply get rid of it. |
@jafant I'm glad to hear that! With modern soldering techniques and the surface mount devices used, it could happen with about any brand I suppose. It makes me a bit uncomfortable given the price of hi-end gear. |
- 8 posts total

