Let's talk music, no genre boundaries


This is an offshoot of the jazz thread. I and others found that we could not talk about jazz without discussing other musical genres, as well as the philosophy of music. So, this is a thread in which people can suggest good music of all genres, and spout off your feelings about music itself.

 

audio-b-dog

One old version of Starker and Fournier  are my two ultimate cello Bach...

Here Starker is magnificent like Milstein for the violin...

But i link Fournier  with Szeryng  then it is my best one  ever , there is a pulse behind Fournier  almost like the one with Szeryng......

 

By the way for the violin concertos i will die with one version only, i did not even kept any other version  since 50 years , for the same reason behind my other choices, musical time born from inside the playing not  imposed from outside on the playing... it is not the best orchestral version but i dont mind...Grumiaux  sing and speak ... His sonatas and partitas were surpassed by others but not his concertos for violins playing ...Just thinking  about it made me feel wings ...it is incredible...

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZEMfHTs1X8o&list=RDZEMfHTs1X8o&start_radio=1

 

@mahgister 

For Bach’s Cello Suites I purchased a recording by Starker. I read that he plays without vibrato (although I probably wouldn’t have noticed on my own). He has a strong determined voice, whereas Yo-Yo Ma seems more fluid. I have streamed Alisa Wielerstein but still have not heard enough to have an opinion.

 

 

Another one I would recommend for Bach Cello suites is Hidemi Suzuki. His playing is exceptional and the sound quality on the SACD makes it even more sumptuous.

 

Suzuki Bach Cello

Thanks i never listen Suzuki ... I will correct that ...

Another one I would recommend for Bach Cello suites is Hidemi Suzuki. His playing is exceptional and the sound quality on the SACD makes it even more sumptuous.

 

Wow  it is on youtube:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zEHXTrJb3HQ&list=RDzEHXTrJb3HQ&start_radio=1

He did not play a modern cello but an old one, his colors mastery are astonishing...

Something we must buy ...

It feel like Helen Schmitt sound recording  quality and articulation...

Amazing and i dont have  all the pieces yet ...

 

@srinisr 

I will stream Suzuki tomorrow. The cello deserves speakers that go down below 80Hz. The youtube sample sounded excellent, though.

@audio-b-dog 

My sense was that "Astrid" played up the "strangeness" of the protagonist, presenting her as some sort of exotic or "alien" creature. It struck me as quite stylized (or perhaps, simply "quite French"?) in this regard. I actually preferred what seemed to me a more "human/humane" portrayal in "Patience", despite the fact that I typically prefer original series to "knock-offs".  Of course, not being knowledgeable re: the spectrum, I can't reliably judge which might be more true-to-life or even if it's a case of either/or. They might be equally valid/invalid, for all I know. I simply related more to Patience. 

Reading about consciousness can be fascinating. Personally, I find connecting with it directly more rewarding.