Walk-in soundstage


Coupled with his Weiss DAC 204 and T+A DAC 200, Mr. Steve Huff claimed to have experienced the so-called "walk-in soundstage" when using the Lumin U2 as the streaming transporter. This refers to a deeply immersive, three-dimensional stereo image where the listener perceives the musical space as so realistic and spacious that it feels as if one could physically walk into the soundstage.

This level of presentation is notably different from the more common “layered” sound field that many average listeners or reviewers report—where the sound is merely projected in front of the listener with some layering or spatial envelopment.

I'm curious how many of you have also experienced this effect in your own systems and listening spaces. If you're open to sharing, I'd love to hear about the components and setup that helped you achieve it.

  

lanx0003

@lanx0003 

I think ESL 63 has similar trait to 57, correct? 

Yes and mainly NO!

Both are electrostatic, so have no box around them to resonate.  The almost-as-light-as-air diaphragms have no overshoot unlike massive conventional drivers. Both are meant to be full range speakers.

But the original ESL (now known as the 57 because 1957 was when it was released) was not conceived for stereo.  It dealt with the problem of flat panels by curving them slightly about a horizontal axis.  It is a three-way design with three panels per speaker and crossovers and compared with modern speakers lies on its side.

The ESL 63 was conceived in 1963, after stereo records became commercially available, but the 63 was not released until 1981.  One of the objectives was to reduce the treble beaminess of the ESL 57 and another was to ensure a long service life - not easy with ultra-light diaphragms charged to over 5,000-Volts in a narrow gap between stators which carry the audio signal transformed to high voltages.  Peter Walker named the 63 "FRED" for full-range electrostatic dipole.  With minor modifications, it and its successors are still in production.

Note that these have no conventional crossovers - another source of distortion removed.  Overly high stator voltages are eliminated by attenuating signal voltages above 40-Volts.  To reduce the possibility of sparking which can burn holes in the diaphragm, an ionization detector could shut the speaker down by in effect making it look like a short circuit to the amplifier.

Alastair Robertson-Aikman, the founder of SME, tried various modification to the ESL-63 including stacking them.  Quad themselves introduced models with 50% more panel area to extend the low bass.

In the last few weeks, Quad has introduced two models with an -X suffix.  One of the things they seem to have done is to add insulation to the stators, and to remove the ionization detector in order to get a bit more volume.

My only real criticism of these speakers is that they don’t play loudly enough in big rooms, especially with the dynamics available from high resolution sources.  One way to boost their apparent output is to pair them with subwoofers.

Although they are big panels, the concentric stator design means they can also be used as near-field monitors which is an easy way to effectively crank-up the apparent volume.

A second criticism is the life of the panels, especially when they were produced in China.  The story is that Peter Walker specified glue with a 10 year minimum service life and the glue maker took him too literally

Swapping, mixing and matching high fidelity components and cables is a long cherished audiophile activity which undoubtedly has produced countless hours of audio enjoyment.

The drawback to this process is the amount of time and expense that it consumes. Today with digital signal processing (DSP) you can tune and optimize your system real time.

First start by combining excellent speakers, modern power amplifiers with a digital source which will leverage Dirac or other DSP System / Room correction algorithms.

Once you have your speakers positioned, the next  step is to optimize your system using tools like REW and Dirac Live room correction. Now you can make adjustments,  listen to the results and measure the results rapidly. It’s enlightening to be able to make adjustments to your system and measure them in real time. About Deer Creek Audio

Here are some examples of Dirac Live correction 

 

 

 

@deer_creek_audio  Thank you for the DSP/RC recommendation. I had been experimenting with Wiim RC/PEQ to boost the missing low end, but since the arrival of the two sub-$1k DACs, the bass has really come alive.  I want to get an external mic. to get more accurate SPL measurement for my room though.

@richardbrand  Thank you for letting me know about the various improvements Quad has made to enhance the performance of the ESL, such as increased volume and improved bass. Has there been any discussion regarding the treble roll-off above 10 kHz (as seen in the ESL 2805)? I’ve never seen a roll-off quite like that.

Geez, people still paying attention to Steve Huff?  The guys a grifter and fraud.  Makes a living talking to the dead with his spirit box, or whatever he calls it.  
Talk about snake oil!!!

I like seeing different gear almost as much as the next guy but can’t stomach Huff.  He should be ashamed of himself.