Neil,
I believe we are in agreement. My concluding sentence "There is more than one way to clean a dirty record, but follow the proven scientific methods."
With respect to Last I have shared this story on this forum before. I was working at a high end stereo shop in San Diego when Last was first introduced. I believe ~1977 or 1978 (?). Anyway the sales rep demonstrated the product as follows: We set up two identical Dual 1229 Turntables, on one a fresh copy of Thelma Houston's Direct To Disc was treated with Last; on the the second an identical copy of same was left untreated. Both were played back and forth to verify that they sounded the same. This was all done in front of a room full of interested customers. The two turntables were left on auto-repeat and left to play for one week. Everyone reconvened and the two were compared again. The stylus on each was checked and cleaned. The untreated record had noticeably deteriorated, but the Last treated record sounded fine. Next it was compared with a third fresh copy of the same record and there was no noticeable difference. The store sold a lot of Last on that day and ever after. I still use it on my best records to this day.

