Dear @mikelavigne : " amp linearity is not an issue. "
Certainly not and that was not my point.. You missed the main issue in my post. You said that at the same SPL the cartridge shows higher " signal energy ".
A good amp ( like yours. ) just amplify what comes at its input with almost no modifications. The amp does not knows if are incoming musical information only or if that musical information comes with high integrated/added distortions ( developed in other system chain's links: cartridge/tonearm/phono stage and the like. The system electronics can't fix those distortions and the best it can do is to reproduce it that way. ) and when amplify the digital signal this signal truly comes with way lower added distortions and that's why lower watts peacks when the analog/cartridge high distortions provoque those high watts peacks. The higher the distortions coming in to the incoming signal amp the higher the amp watts peacks.
This is not just an argument but something you have to understand because you just did not what I explained before.
" digital rounds off the top of the transient compared to the analog..."
that goes totally against what normally happens that's the other way around. Almost all LP lovers make a negative critic of the HF agresiveness of digital even hardness or brithness down there. Did you directly made the digital transfer?, the latest CD came from 2013 and as almost everyone know the original Pablo recording came from sept. 1974 and you know that are a lot of analog and digital re-issues. Analogue Productions has 4 LP re-issues, I own the HQ and the original Pablo label.
R.