High definition vs. tonal balance


After many, many years as an audiophile, I’ve come to a conclusion that a goal of tonal balance is far more rewarding and less crazy producing than the quest for greater and greater definition.
Of course, both together is Nirvana.  But so many audiophiles go awry in the holy quest for lucidity.
Years ago I had a system that was far less defined than the system I have today. But, tonally, it was in perfect balance.  A violin sounded like a violin, an oboe like an oboe, a trumpet like a trumpet, you get the idea.  But, it was lacking in those elusive fine points of definition that I thought I needed.
Then began a many year’s quest to find the right component, wire, fuse, what have you to get the sharpest picture I could attain.  Trouble is, I would improve one aspect at the expense of another.  More piling on of fixes and I couldn’t get to the place of happiness I had before I started.
Finally, probably by luck and after thousands of dollars I’ve reached the point of content I was at several years ago.
Maybe my system is better defined now, but it also has achieved that synergy.
My point is, was it worth the torture?



128x128rvpiano
Post removed 
Excellent topic. 

It is amazing how many folks in the hobby believe that "transparency" is the end-all. 

Transparency, along with three-dimensional imaging and dynamics are all part of the picture. But if correct tonality isn't there, then the music won't be emotionally involving.

With the right tweaks, all is possible ... without changing/upgrading equipment.

Frank
Far as I’m concerned; if a system is truly, "transparent", or- "high-definition", it’ll pass whatever, "tonality" is in the recording and all other musical/venue information, without editorializing anything. Hopefully, presenting a reasonable facsimile, of the event. That’s not, "Nirvana". It’s just accuracy!
Years ago I had a system that was far less defined than the system I have today. But, tonally, it was in perfect balance.

How would you know? By that, I mean versus today.

Perfect tonality without accuracy (transparency, clarity,...) Hmmm....

+1 rodman