Anyone tried Magnepan 1.6's with rock music?


I am just wondering if they work alright with 70's classic rock music. Do you need a sub ?
Thanks, Scott
scottht
I have a pair of 1.5s driven with 100 watts solid state and a tube preamp. I have the impression so far that more power would help them to shine with rock music, but with other music I am totally in love with them. I feel alot of great rock songs were not the greatest recordings and since these speakers really show things the way they are upstream, the higher volume levels most of us would play rock songs at make the bad ones even worse. My amp may not have the iron grip on the panels the way a more powerful one would, and that would definitely help in the bass. If you want to shake things in the house with every beat then I would look elsewhere, but if imaging and purity of tone are important give them a listen.
They make rock...Rock! I miss mine. A good transducer like the 1.6QR or any Maggie should be able to play anything and everything and excel at it. I have measured 114db outside my back door playing 3rd eye blind! And they were only cranked about half way.
I have 3.6s, but also had smga's and 2.somethings, here are some comments:

Dark Side of the Moon - absolutely amazing. 'Time' is better than most speakers because of the way things flow from maggies. You will do well with all of the Floyd stuff.

LedZep, Whole Lotta Love - this is an example of a fairly well recorded 70's song, sounds awesome! And the 3.6s at least have plenty of grunt for the grunty sections.

Rush - old stuff - sounds horrible! Very flat and 2 dimensional. I got the 'gold' recent re-release and compression is so high I prefer the original CDs I bought in early 80s! As they got older the recordings got better. Moving Pictures closed the 70s (1981) and it is pretty good, but I still feel a sense of flatness. When I listened to my Rush 'tapes' back in the day I remember always trying to get more out of them via tone controls and never quite making it work.

Fleetwood Mac - well you know how female vocals do on Maggies!

Early Ronny James Dio - pretty moderate/low, but when it is just him singing great, late Dio, darn good.

If you get into some of the rock that is less clean, when they have 3 or 4 guitar players, it kind of sounds... annoying. You can really hear all of what looking back may seem like noise. On the other hand, some stuff that in my memory is a bit 'muddled' like Hendrix for example, cleans up really well on modern stuff - instruments and people separate, there is more music and less 'noise' if that makes sense. I honestly feel more connected on good equipment.

I'd say go for it if you like some of the cleaner stuff, also don't know if you are more on the softer or harder side - if on the softer side (which can potentially include Simon and Garfunkel although technically that is folk, no?) that comes out awesome.

If you want to rock out to bands with all the 'rythm guitar' players added to the standard 3 or 4 person band, then I actually like the horn idea above. Kilpsch does some interesting horn stuff that isn't super exotic or expensive.

Best way to find out - take your 10 favourite CDs to a local dealer and try them on the 1.6s! Try Whole Lotta Love and Time - you'll be blown away!!!

If you want to rock out 70s style, then get these:

https://www.klipsch.com/products/details/la-scala-ii.aspx

and a good record player (which will probably also breathe life into some of the 'flatter' stuff on CD from early or mid 70s). You will have an awesome 70s den. They are a bit more than the 1.6s, but not crazy. (I'm tempted to get them for a 70s garage system now that I'm thinking about this :) )

But, honestly, if you listen to Time and Whole Lotta love on a well-amped 1.6 system, I think you will have a hard time not getting the 1.6s.
Give me a few days, & I'll let you know the difference between modded SMGa's & MMG's with Magnestand frames & crossovers! I just made the deal here on A-gon, & I feel like a kid at Christmas!I'm running a DIY amp with 150 wpc & lots of PS guts, a tube linestage, & Denon MM cart thru a Bugle phono pre. The SMGa's sound pretty damn good- lots of dynamics & imaging is super, but I can't wait to hear PG's magic!