iPod Confessional


I've had an iPod (40 GB version) for four days now, and I must confess that it has been a huge kick. Despite my audiophile reservations (how could anything this small hold hundreds of my CDs and still sound good??), I've fallen in love with this thing.

Part of my rationale (and spousal justification process) was that my wife has wanted for a long time to have all-day Christmas music during the holidays. I used to provide this with 10.5" reel to reel tapes, but that's long gone. I'd thought about a mega-changer, but could never get enthusiastic about a big black box in my very inconspicuous living room system (Linn Classik and B&W 303s). But the iPod with the docking station and line out serves this purpose perfectly. The other night, I just selected "Vocal" as a genre, and enjoyed a great selection of music all throughout a long dinner. And needless to say, my commute just got a whole lot more enjoyable (especially with Eyptomic ER-6s to shut out the noise.)

As much as I like the satisfaction of holding a CD in my hand, and popping it in the player, I really think the iPod and other such players will eventually increase demand for server-type audio systems in the home. (I know, Linn makes one, but I'm thinking of something mortals can afford.)

I'm sure the MP3 files (even at the 320 kbps bite rate I'm using) are no match for the original for critical listening, I just don't find nearly as much time for critical listening as I would like. Now I'm getting to spend more time enjoying my music collection, and that's what it's all about, right?
rsuminsby
Monster makes a better quality cable that can be used to connect the iPod to any device equipped with stereo RCA type jacks. By itself the iPod is not an audiophile component. It is a wonderful lifestyle product that allows someone to carry around large amounts of easily accessible music. The built-in D/A is its main limitation.
Kimber also makes "high end" iPod cables--sold through the headroom amp people. I'd echo Onhwy61's comments, however.
I also have had a 30gb ipod for a few months and think it's absolutely fantastic. A sacrifice in sound quality is so much preferred over no music at all. I also have the line out into my stereo, but it sounds so thin and lifeless, much more so than one can attribute to it being mp3. Maybe I'll try the Kimber cable.

Spizm, I am trying to do exactly what you have set up in your house right now. What computer sound card are you using? I'm wondering if using a USB outboard soundcard into a dac would be a significant improvement over internal soundcard into a dac.
Ultraviolet - what bit rate are you using to rip your MP3s? I've ripped most of my disks at 320 kbps, and have been pretty happy with the results for background listening.
I've ripped my mp3's using Exact Audio Creater and the lame mp3 decoder. I use the alt-preset-standard setting which produces variable bit rate mp3's. I think they average ~192kbps. It was explained to me though that VBR that averages ~192 supposedly sounds better than just regular 192 kbps. Anyone know if this is actually the case?

How big are files encoded at 320? Are they appreciably smaller than the uncompressed wav file? Do you think there would be a considerable audible difference between my mp3s and yours? Thanks for the help. I'd love to find a happy medium between mp3s sounding passible on the home stereo and still small enough that I can carry quite a bit around on the ipod.