Vandersteen Subwoofer decision


I know you are going to think this is yet another repeat of the question of whether the 2wq is that much better than the 2w, but this one is different. I own a 2w and I am looking to add second Vandy sub so I will have one for each of my front speakers. Seems to me like I would have three options: 1) buy another 2w for about $500, 2) buy a 2wq for about $800 used, or 3) sell the 2w and buy 2-2wq's for about a $1200 total investment. Anybody have an opinion? My first inclination is to just buy another 2w, as I don't see where my "Q" needs a lot of adjustment.
anotheraudiguy
Dear friend: Adding a second sub to your system could transform ( for the better ) your audio quality system sound reproduction: right decision.

I think that this link can help you about: http://forum.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/fr.pl?eanlg&1117893153&openflup&27&4#27

Regards and enjoy the music.
Raul.
The decision to add another 2W versus a 2Wq is a personal judgement call, as you may not notice a significant performance difference in stepping up to a pair of 2Wq's. About a year ago, I had a chance to talk personally with Richard Vandersteen while he was in Seattle to conduct a seminar at a local dealership, and I asked him about the differences between the two subs. He commented that there are two differences:
1. The most obvious difference is the ability to "tune" the Q on the 2Wq. I have found in my own system (which has a pair of 2Wq's) that adjusting the Q does make a useful, although not dramatic, improvement in the overall quality of the bass. I think that the amount of improvement will be dependent on the main speakers you have, the acoustic properties of your listening room, and where the subs are placed in the room.
2. The built-in amplifier in the 2Wq is of better quality than the one in the 2W, and if you are using the sub(s) with high-quality main speakers, the 2Wq will provide somewhat better bass reproduction.

Personally, I would not match your 2W with a 2Wq. Either get a pair of 2Wq's, or add a second 2W, and thus avoid the possibility of different audio qualities from having two different subs. The one distinct advantage to having a pair of 2Wq's is that you can tune the contour of the "Q" for use with both music and home theater.

Your post does not mention what type of main speakers you are using, so bear in mind that Vandersteen's subs are optimized for use with main speakers that have flat response down to about 40 Hz. This allows the main speakers and the sub(s) to overlap by one octave, which is a major factor in getting the seamless blend that Vandy subs are known for.
Get the q's so I can buy your 2w. Let me know before you list it. My room works great with the 2w. Thanks.
Been down that road the 2wq is nicer because of the q lets you taylor the bass to the room a little better. Now the question is do you need that. Unfortionally no one can answer that. If you find the bass is boomey (which is really hard for a sub that fast to do) get the q if you are satified wiht hte 2w just get another 2w and save the cash. I would also not sugest using a 2w and a 2wq they will just not match. If you are going to go for 2 2wq you may want to look into the quadros at that point.
Thanks for the insight all. Since I have my room tuned quite well for bass, can put the things wherever I want, have a seperate sub (bag end) for movies and am about $4000 over budget for my system, I think I will get the next great deal on a 2W.

Randy
Anotheraudiguy, It sounds like you are making the right decision. On a music only basis, adding the 2W will sound great and it seems like your room works well with the 2W's Q. When I owned a pair of 2WQs I felt that it was useful to adjust the Q if I wanted the bass to be more obvious (looser, more overhang, e.g. home theater, quick sale impressive)but for music I did not want the bass to be so "obvious" - the 2Ws are tuned for music. Enjoy.