Based on your wants in sound quality, that would lean heavily toward a tube based CD player. I used the EAR Acute 3 in the past, put Amperex 7308 tubes in it, and was exactly what you are talking about. These are my tastes as well. It only did redbook CD though (no SACDs). It does have a pretty good DAC too. I got mine used for around $3000.
Other tube units are AMR, Cary, etc. Solid-state doesn't match the full-bodied and smooth sound of tubes, but does better in detail and other facets. Just my experience with digital components thus far.