Most Influential American Musician of All Time?


Who do you regard as the most influential (i.e., musically, not necessarily commercially) American musician of all time across all genres?

The more I learn about Louis Armstrong, the more I am persuaded that he deserves that honor.
jeffreybowman2k

Showing 3 responses by tubegroover

I agree with Jeffery. I really can't think of anyone that comes close to his influence from a historical perspective although I'm sure some will say Miles Davis but not from a musician's standpoint IMO atlthough his music was certainly innovative and took jazz in a different direction. What is unique about Louis Armstrong is that he gave his instrument a voice that was unheard of up until that time and was built on by subsequent musicians. The major icon of jazz.
Gershwin is probably my favorite American songwriter/composer on any given day but the question is influential musician not greatest songwriter. Is Gershwin even the most influential songwriter of the jazz era? I don't think he is. That would probably go to WC Handy or maybe Scott Joplin. Their music is at the root of blues and jazz respectively.

Some of the answers are getting off point IMO and yes, this is purely a subjective exercise, none of it can be proven. A great case can be made for Elvis. How many ten's of thousands of impersonators has his influence begat? All seriousness aside he is a major influence as a musician? Yes, if you count a singer in the equation but then the question should be most influential singer? While a singer is technically a musician it never entered my mind to consider individuals know as singers (i.e. Sinatra, Presley, Fitzgerald, Vaughn, Holiday, Madonna etc) or songwriters (i.e. Gershwin, Porter, Arlen, Berlin, Dylan). I certainly consider many of the above excellent musicians but their influence is greater as
Singers and/or Songwriters. I was thinking along the lines of a musical instrument musician. Is that the intent of the question or do singers and songwriters count as well?

Leonard Berstein and Arthur Fiedler are probably the most influential personalities that brought orchestral and classical music to the masses. Does anyone remember Berstein's show in the 50's something like "Young people's guide to the Orchestra" I was greatly influenced by that show as a kid as I'm sure many more were. But for the question posed I don't think these guys count. The question requires narrower boundaries. What do you say Jeffery, its your thread?
"Tvad, FWIW I think your definition of 'musician' might be a bit narrow, especially in view of how it's defined in my dictionary, i.e. a composer or performer of music and as an alternative a performer esp of instrumental music."

This goes back to my question Jeffery, how do we define musician for the benefit of this thread? Does it include composers and singers or is the intent instrumentalist? If so it is an impossible question to answer and would have to be divided into categories otherwise it is nothing more than a popularity contest with no objective basis for argument.