I own both, 3" thick maple from Mapleshade and Butcher Block Acoustic. They are both excellent and I cannot hear a difference between the two products. I’d suggest you purchase whichever one is more pleasing to your eyes or within your price range. Honestly, you can’t go wrong they are both excellent.
Butcher Block Acoustic has a greater selection of options.
Butcher Block Acoustic has a greater selection of options.