Long ICs - A'gon versus Audiocircle


Here on Audiogon there have been many discussions about long vs. short ICs, with (to my recollection) no real bias for one or other other. I happen to fall into the long IC camp (given that I have to choose one or the other), because I've tried them both in my system and long ICs seem to work better.

I've just been noticing, however, that on Audiocircle there appears (again, to me) to be a real bias against long ICs. The prevailing justification seems to be that of high frequency roll off. Now I like AC as an alternate place to discuss things audio, but I get the sense that this subject will be less likely to turn into a holy war here.

What is the viability of this argument against long ICs? How long does a low capacitance (figure around 12-16 pf/ft) single ended IC have to get before there is any hit on the upper end of the audio band?
tonyptony

Showing 1 response by chazzbo

Serus
Was suprised to read in Mappleshade catalog same thing that you said was "traditional" thinking that folks should use short IC paths (less distorion) and longer speaker cables.Still have a hard time undertsanding on why a 12ft run of same wire with speakers should be than 6 ft.I just assumed more wire for heat and friction to build up there as with interconnects.Me I am helping a freind set up his Magnepans and I told him that even if we went with a very cheap wire (somebody sugested Blue jeans wire and their stuff is very cheap/inexpensive depending on how you see it) .Want to use it so we can move his 2 gear racks from in between his speakers and big 40" CD storage "spinners" (set a bit back and to sides).I told him that even though one should go balanced/unbalanced/balanced to often (think I read that in /Stereophile's Hartley's book) that going RCA as ins the 30 ft or more of wire would require XLR wires-so we can open up the area around his speakers.But his amp I thought could sit on rack and I thought short run would make sense but you and others say no and I just can't wrap my head around it.I have also been told by some my idea that without some testing software or newer adjustable pre like the DEQX don't assume I'll get benefits from removing stuff but I still think it's worth the try.But again even if we use very cheap wires to do it.But why the length and how long?Are there specs I should ask from Maggie or Bryston which we are trying to buy?
Thanks
Chazz