Help me decide between these two turntable/cartridge combinations


In about 6 weeks I plan to pull the trigger on a new turntable/cartridge combination. I have narrowed it down, and am torn between the following two:

·         Rega Planar 8 with Apheta 2 Cartridge ($4295)

·         EAT C-Sharp with Ortofon Quintet Black ($3,995)

These two turntable/cartridge combinations are at the very limit of what I can spend – in fact the Rega is really pushing the limit. I’m looking at these combinations because of the discount that comes from bundling these cartridges with the turntable – plus they come installed from the factory.

One of the requirements I have is that the turntable must have a low profile – the total height cannot exceed 5.3 inches. This rules out other models like ones from VPI, Pro-Ject, etc.

These two turntables take totally different approaches – with the Rega being very lightweight and rigid, vs. the EAT which weighs three times what the Rega weighs.

The equipment I would be using it with – a Parasound P6 preamp and A21 Power Amplifier, and B&W 702s2 speakers with DB4S Subwoofer. The listening area is a finished basement – wall-to-wall carpeted with padding underneath, on top of concrete, so a good strong foundation is in place.

I listen to about 50% classical, 25% Jazz/Blues and 25% classic rock. Most of my records are fairly high quality – MoFi Original Master Recordings, Deutsche Grammophon, etc.

I’ve searched through this forum – the Rega has received great comments (as well as great reviews from the magazines). Not as much on the EAT, although Absolute Sound was fairly positive. I found it interesting in this forum someone got the EAT and returned it due to mechanical noise/vibration (through the Audio). They replaced it with the Rega P8 which did not have this problem.

One possible concern – I sometimes play my records loud, and my speakers are only about 4-5 feet away from where the turntable is. I’m wondering which of these two might be better under these circumstances. It does not seem to be a problem with my current turntable – a 35 year old Bang and Olufsen 2404 turntable with MMC-2 cartridge.

Comments? Which one would you prefer and why, or would you recommend some other table/cartridge combination that is low profile and under $4,000?
btanchors

Showing 1 response by millercarbon

Well first off neither one of these is gonna disappoint, both will easily take you places never dreamed of by B&O. That said my turntable philosophy tends to favor mass. In this case though the mass is low-tech MDF. And they can say what they want about it being ultra-high density, whatever, its still compressed wood particles in a glue bound matrix. So they cover it with carbon fiber. Big deal. I've worked with carbon fiber. My whole turntable is made out of it. Did I mention I built my own turntable? So I know. Carbon fiber is great but not sufficient in itself. 

The thing about the Rega, its a filter-down of technology from a much more expensive higher performance table. EAT is pretty good but it will be years, if ever, by the time they have high tech like that to filter down. They are still trying to figure out what exactly the appropriate high tech is. Rega has decades on them.

Okay so its a stretch. Big deal. Unlike most of the other audio gear you could buy with that money the Rega is one you can run for years. I've got 15 years on my table.

That's about the only other thing you might want to consider, longevity and future upgrades. You're at a price point where I usually recommend staying away from packages and buying turntable, arm, and cartridge separately. Even if bought all together. What I mean is stay away from either of these and look for a really good table with an arm you like and a decent cartridge, in that order. Because this makes it so much easier down the road to upgrade just the arm, or even just the table. This is a lot harder with package tables like Rega, EAT, VPI, etc. Also because when upgrading its a whole lot easier to save up $5k for a killer arm than $20k for a killer turntable package. Plus you get way more performance for your money.

But that's about it. Separates are the ultimate, but if you can't see yourself going that way then it doesn't matter. Go with the Rega, and never look back.