Foil damping tape as a tonearm tube wrap?


There has been a couple sporadic posts recently about using a product called 3M foil damping tape to wrap tonearm tubes. The tape is normally used in applications to reduce unwanted vibrations in the product to which the tape is attached. In the particular tonearm wrap applications, users claim a noticeable improvement in sonic qualities of vinyl playback. I created this thread to catalog impressions of others who have used this material, their particular tonearm wrap applications and their take away stories. Who has used this product for tonearm wraps? Thoughts?
128x128celander

Showing 9 responses by celander

@nationbar pm’ed me about his experience with this tweak. Here is the gist of that pm:

“Hello, The product I use is 3M Damping Foil (tape), # 2552 It is a constrained layer damping tape. Here is the product sheet on 3M's web site: https://www.3m.com/3M/enUS/company-us/all-3m-products/~/3M-Damping-Foil-2552/?N=5002385+3293194280&a... I use the 1" x 5 yards roll (that's enough to do fifteen tonearms!) I buy it from Grainger, they have the best price and they sell smaller quantities, most industrial sources only offer large quantities. Here: https://www.grainger.com/search?searchBar=true&searchQuery=3m+2552 Forget about the description on Grainger's website re:" EMI absorber tape", that's for another product altogether. The product is indeed 3M 2552. I wrap the armtube only, from just behind the headshell collet, up to but stopping at the bearing lug section, where it gets bigger.. just behind the arm lock. I wrap-carefully- in a spiral, with about 50% overlap. Beware, the adhesive is strong- I actually spoke to an engineer at 3M in Minnesota to enquire about removing the tape from a magnesium tube. he said removal requires a 4 pound pull for the adhesive to release. The reason I am damping the arm this way, as well as using the KAB fluid damping system and the arche headshell is the London Reference cartridge I use is very low compliance, and sends a LOT of energy down the tonearm tube, which feeds back to the stylus. The 3M damping tape is FAR more effective than teflon plumbers tape or heat shrink tubing. The combination of all three elements, the arche headshell, the damping tape, and the KAB fluid damping system, eliminated the mechanical quirks from the London cartridge, allowing it to track properly, and also it lowered surface noise, which this cartridge is known for. The tape wrapped on the armtube added about 6 grams of weight, so remember to re-adjust your VTF.”
I reviewed the E.A.R. foil product at the Michael Percy Audio site. (To be honest, I was surprised to learn he’s still using a journal-styled product catalog—hasn’t changed in like 20+ years!) Only downside is one has to cut a strip from the sheet. I’m not great with exacto knives or scissors. 😬
@lewm while I’m the OP, this particular application was reported by @nationalbar. I have no experience with his setup to offer an opinion. Please review my post of a private message that includes his findings. He’s happy with the resolution to his concerns.
Ugh....
Sigh....
I will repeat this just once more: I haven’t tried this method of tonearm damping.

I posted a private message from one member named @nationalbar who swears by the method using his tonearm, headshell and cartridge setup. 

3M 434 is barely temperature optimal for home environments, having an upper working temp of 20C. Trust me, I checked all of 3M foils for their specifications. 3M 2552 is more effective across a larger, more relevant temperature range normally encountered in home environments.