Does Mid-Woofer Size Relate to a Speaker's Realism


It could be argued that a small mid-woofer is 'quicker' in its response to signal-input and, therefore, more realistic in transient response. Is this true?

It could also be argued that a large mid-woofer is better able to reproduce the lower tones of the midrange in a more realistic manner. Is this true?

Is either choice better at realistic reproduction, overall?

[Since I do have strong views on the subject, as the O.P., I'd prefer to remain outside any ensuing discussion, as much as possible, on this one, if that's O.K.]
waj4all

Showing 4 responses by mapman

"Does Mid-Woofer Size Relate to a Speaker's Realism "

"Mr_m
I'm waiting for mapman's response!"

My answer is: Yes.
100hz?

Is that common in many expensive 2 ways?

Some examples?

Seems like a bad idea to me but i am no expert.
Waj,

Thanks for the examples. As you can see those are all 3 ways where the
low crossover frequency makes more sense, not 2 ways. Big difference!
I agree with stanwal. It always helps to understand the princip!es behind
design, but there is no one right way for all for all the reasons cited plus
many others that deal with peoples needs and budgets as much as
technology.

Great discussion though!